Ok, so before I read through the thread again, I looked at all the wagons that happened day 1 (6 of them reached L-1, if you include Robz twice), and I noticed two players standing out, having voted on 4 of the 6, including the final one, which hit confirmed town.
- chairs/Teproc : obviously can't say much on that.
- mail-mi
Now obviously this isn't damning in and of itself. mail-mi was the hammer on faust, but I think I would have been ready to hammer as well given faust's last post and the deadline looming. Still, it definitely made we pay extra attention to his voting behavior.
Brushing aside his first three votes (two RVS, one against chairs/Teproc about theory talk), here is his record :
A reads post cuz I'm on a bus and heck why not.
[...]
3. Robz888--vote: robz has like 1 post.
You seem so... different. Less jokey, which I associate with your town self. Maybe it's because it's your first time being scum? Yeah, still fine with wagon. In fact, vote: walrus
[...]
Faust... I could go for Faust. Better than Robz, IMO. Vote: Faust.
Voltaire comes out of that exchange much scummier than Yuma, and Faust probably isn't going through, so vote: Voltaire.
However, I am also okay with keeping on volt. So I'll stay there, but intent to hammer if someone else switches.
Why not switch now and then let someone else hammer?
Cuz I wanna hammer! vote: faust
Okay, so let's see how these hold up :
#88 : First vote on the first Robz wagon. Seems fair, Robz had been completely absent by that point.
#157 : Third vote on the Walrus wagon. This one seems fair as well. He has a read on Walrus that he is behaving differently, so it definitely makes sense to jump on the wagon here.
#306 : Second vote on faust at the time, just after Walrus put Robz to L-1 again. In this post, he says that Walrus is behaving more normally (the Joker gif I think) and he has a null read on Robz. This one is a little more problematic because there's just no reasoning for the vote. Granted, yuma had made his case against faust a couple posts ago, but still, mail-mi doesn't look great here.
#423: Third vote on the Voltaire wagon. No reasoning again, except that Voltaire "looks scummy" in his exchange with yuma.
Here's the reason he gives when pressed :
Voltaire comes out of that exchange much scummier than Yuma, and Faust probably isn't going through, so vote: Voltaire.
Why. Please give a reason.
Mostly a feeling from skimming it over. I am currently in school.
Also, tou have a town read on me. That's not normal.
Not exactly an air-tight case.
#498 : Hammer on faust. Again, no particular reasoning, which can be attributed to the deadline looming and the fact that Walrus had also expressed his willingness to hammer.
Now I mentioned that mail-mi was on 4 of the 6 wagons. Well actually, he seemed pretty close to hammer chairs/Teproc when he was at L-1 here :
Ummm... Intent to hammer, I guess?
In fact, had yuma not specifically asked for people not to hammer without announcing it first, I might very well not have been in this game, and what kind of world would that have been ?
So mail-mi was in on ALL the wagons Day 1. You could argue that he wasn't on the second Robz wagon, but it did not last very long, and it seemed like town was not ready to lynch Robz, since he had survived L-1 effortlessly earlier.
Not only that, but, aside from the first two votes quoted here, here is a list of wagons mail-mi is ready to join at #349 (during the chairs/Teproc wagon) :
Ya know what, other than the Robz wagon a little bit, I'm pretty much good with all the wagons right now. Order of preference;
Faust
Chairs
Walrus
(Robz)
Notice that Voltaire isn't on there, yet mail-mi eagerly joined in against him at #423.
The fact that he hammered a VT wouldn't be a big deal normally, given the circumstances discussed above. However, this looks to me like a textbook exemple of scum pretty efficiently lurking and getting on anything that even resembles a wagon, and finally hammering when it's obvious that it can't be used against him.
vote: mail-miP.S : Sorry for the huge wall of text, I tried to make it as concise as possible by shortening a few quotes, but that clearly wasn't enough.