I'm trying to address the case on me as I see it, feel free to correct me if I've misunderstood something.
-Lack of activity / disappearing at the end of day 1
Look, I know it sucks. I'm spinning further and further away from the top posted I once was. I did a similar disappearing act twice in MC. I know it's bad and very antitown, but there has been some stretches where I haven't gone to a computer for a week, really doesn't bode well with mafia playing. No excuse here, other than that the more active members of the community probably noticed how I wasn't posting anywhere else that the time, either. When I promised to catch up and never did, I got 1/3 through, then friends came over to a surprise visit, we ended up going out and when I sat down on the computer to finish the job the following afternoon/evening, I noticed that the thread had already been locked. I'm terrible with keeping deadlines in mind.
-Never expanding on the walrus-case
Well, it started from the discrepancy in his play I noticed (even though no one seemed to agree with it). I went back to reread the beginning of MC, and my impressions matched what I found. Now, I understand I said I'd revisit the case and make it prettier, but laziness and the realization that Walrus himself is demanding me to do it - saying I only have one concrete example to show got the better of me. Once I had told walrus what it was that I found suspicious, he obviously had the option of stopping doing it. I thought that doing the work to try to find more examples wouldn't be fruitful, as I kind of tipped my hand to him earlier. Starting to suspect him from early on obviously caused me to look at his posts through a different lens, but nothing he has done since has really made me reconsider the read - I scumhunt mainly through PoE, and while other people have plopped town towny content (like Teproc) or towny claims (like EFHW), Walrus hasn't really done any of that.
What else, I'm forgetting?
PPE4, I type slow