1. So, EFHW hasn't had a town read in the game. This is true IIRC.
How is that scummy ? Being suspicious of everyone seems like the definition of town to me.
Well, you answered that actually, but it seems like a stretch to me. Isn't scum more likely to actively have town reads on people because then these people will think : "Oh, he/she's so perceptive and sees I'm town !"
I strongly disagree. Like emphatically and exuberantly disagree. See my posts above about this but I'll say more again here. When you are scum, once you have a town read you need a really good reason to move your vote. Or else you attract tremendous attention. And for scum they don't care about finding people townie... they already know everyone is town. So their attention is on making people look scum.
The fact that EFHW doesn't have town reads means she isn't scum hunting. She is just trying to make people look scummy. She isn't trying to separate out who is town and who is scum. This is very, very, very scummy to me because it actually goes into the mindsets of someone as scum and shows what scum's true motivation is. I would be extremely surprised if EFHW is town. Obviously I am not 100% sure, but I would put my confidence up in the 75% range or even higher, which is extremely high for me. It is rare enough that I even feel comfortable putting a number on it.
2. This is what's worrying me. This vote against Eevee reads as barely disguised OMGUS, and she had one or two of those already day 1.
3. Do you mean not responding day 1 ? I think she did, and specified Pirates was the one she was talking about. I'l have to reread that exchange.
Add in another OMGUS vote on me just now.
As for point three. She did respond and said Pirates was the one she was talking about. But in that post she implied that there were other games, just that Pirates was the most significant. I went back and checked and found out that there weren't any other games. That pirates was the only one. This makes me think that she might have been using pirates as an exaggeration as an appeal to emotion.
I will note here that I am not sure why that Pirates game would have such an impact on her (I am sorry if it did)... she survived through the whole thing and wasn't mislynched. I did suspect her, but it wasn't like she was lynched because of it.