Ok
So first:
I'm sorry. I should have seen that munch / joth needed to be doctor, and thus lyching one guaranteed the doctor kill. I had kindof forgotten somehow that the other 2 had claimed VT. I still think that Axxle was kindof scummy in his response, and I probably would have wanted to kill him anyway.
Second: FOS everyone else for not noticing it / calling it out either. Volt - this looks especially bad for you.
Frisk, do you mean that either "Axxle or Munch" needed to be doctor? You said in your opening post of Day 3 that you figured Munch was the doctor - and you also said your plan would likely result in the doctor dying. I thought you were assuming that risk - you seemed to have noticed it and taken it into account.
Qvist / Volt
Please analyze asher and yuma. Who do you think is the most likely scum and why?
I explained why I think asher is more likely scum upthread. Leaving aside ash's scummy responses today and reneging on the plan to lynch Qvist if Axxle flipped town, the fact is that one of the two scenarios is true:
(1) If ash is scum: On Day 2, scum!joth and scum!ash jumped 1-2 on the yumawagon I started, in an effort to lynch yuma. Scum!Qvist was unwilling to be the hammer on a wagon made predominantly of scum. Then the wagon fizzled out (no thanks to joth's and ash's efforts to keep it going).
Or:
(2) If yuma is scum: On Day 2, scum!joth bussed yuma and allowed his wagon to stay at L-1 for an extended period of time, during which there was significant risk of yuma being lynched. This at a time when the lynch of any scum player would break scum's stranglehold on the town's power roles.
I think (1) is significantly more likely than (2). So I think ash is more likely than not the last scum.