At the request of the mods, I have agreed not to quit this game. Mcmc has apologized and I have accepted. I'd rather not discuss that stuff and just leave it in the past. Let's just leave it at that, if that's okay with everyone.
I am still in the game, but probably won't post that much for the rest of today. I've prepared what I think is important to say, and will leave it to the town to decide what to do.
1) In response to mcmc's accusation that I'm lying:
Of course he's going to say that. Caught scum has to say the town PR that caught them is lying. The fact of the matter is, when you look at when I revealed the result, there is no good reason for it coming from scum as a lie. It is Day 2 and scum is in a pretty good position, having gotten a mislynch and a night kill through already. It's just not smart scum play. Did it look polished and planned out? Of course it did. I had the result since before my first post of D2. I thought it through completely. I decided when and how I would reveal the result. In the end, town needs to decide which person to believe. I know I'm telling the truth, and I think it is pretty clear.
More on how this is not a smart scum play. Why do this D2? Possibly to save a scum partner, I guess. But we weren't even nearing a lynch when I revealed. I revealed because of timing issues for when the day is supposed to end. I revealed because I thought we had gotten enough interactions and information to analyze. I see no positives in a fake claim by scum unwarranted at that time of the game. Mcmc's claim, on the other hand, was under pressure of death, and makes more sense for scum to make.
2) Why mcmc's claim is clearly fake:
A few reasons, of course. His claim came under pressure, and after he said he wouldn't claim anything at all. I think that looks especially bad, and his claim is desperation. The fact that he says he is a JK, which I find very unlikely to be included anyway, and that he jailed liopoil, which doesn't jive at all with his D2 play. I mean, I had a result from N1, and it changed my entire demeanor for D2. I played with purpose. But mcmc claims he knew the entire time that liopoil didn't do the kill, or anything, and yet nothing changed from his D1 tunnel. He could still be scum that didn't kill, sure, but not doing the kill is a fact if mcmc is telling the truth, and he should have taken that into account in his reads/posts. He didn't. It's because he didn't jail anyone.
More on why I think JK is unlikely. I am a Tracker, and we know we have an IC. These aren't overpowered roles in a small game. I mentioned Bus Driver as the only thing that could clear mcmc...it's a sensible scum counter role to the Tracker (or a Watcher, I guess), since it deals with who did what, not alignments. If I was a Cop, I would think a Godfather more likely. Why do I think these things? I've modded a lot of games, including creating set-ups with balance in mind. C9++, which I've run twice, is a gold standard for balance and doesn't even include JKs. JK + IC is overpowered, since the IC gets confirmed, then is protected the rest of the game, without taking anything away from the role (which is the usual drawback of doctoring as a JK).
So, to recap: mcmc's claim came under pressure, seems unlikely in the setup, and his "usage" of the power doesn't jive with a true town PR. Then, the knowledge he should have gained had no effect on his play, and I still don't believe the "I didn't know Robz was IC" claim, either. Mcmc is lying.
3) What we should do.
Clearly, we should lynch mcmc. But what I mean is, we should definitely lynch mcmc or me. I think scum suggested leaving both claimants alive in Pirates and mislynched to win. We need to lynch a claimant here. So town should decide who they believe, and go from there.
I was super excited about this, being a town PR and actually catching scum. In DS9, as the Detective, I finally caught scum on like N4, but he got killed by the other scum team, so I've never been able to help town like this before. It's part of why I was so worried with how anti-town I had been perceived as in recent games, too. I knew I had an uphill battle to fight on this. I hope I was able to at least make a difference.
I'm not going to go back and quote and reply to specific things, unless you ask me to. Or, feel free to quote and/or ask again if there were specific questions. I don't really want to re-read particular pages. I think I've laid out my thoughts pretty well here, and hopefully it's enough for my fellow townies to understand where I'm coming from.