Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Qvist]

When did I tried to start a bandwagon? Can you quote me?

@Qvist:  It doesn't strike you as the least bit odd that EVERYONE thinks CF is scummy?  If Everyone thinks CF is scummy that includes scum.  This could be seen as scum pushing a towny for a mislynch or fingering their scum buddy for some cred.  I would agree that CF looks fishy but I think I want to see a flip before I lynch him as the "everyone thinks CF is scummy" can be seen in more than one way.

Huh? If everyone would think that CF is scummy than we wouldn't be in that position. Eevee and Voltgloss has him at #5 and jotheonah at #6. What I meant was directed at you and ashersky. So I make it more direct as it seemed not understandable.
@TheMunch and ashersky? Why don't you vote for Captain_Frisk? But I don't expect that Captain_Frisk gets killed tonight because beside of us 3 there seem no-one willing to vote for him.

No, you are putting this out of context. If everyone would think that CF is scummy than we wouldn't be in that position. was a response to that EVERYONE thinks CF is scummy Maybe my English grammar is wrong here. You stated that everyone thinks CF is scummy and I pointed out that this isn't true because then CF would have been already dead. And TheMunch and ashersky had put him at #1 in their list and weren't voting for him. This wasn't the start of a bandwagon. I just wanted to hear their reasoning behind this.

[Captain_Frisk]

When did I tried to start a bandwagon? Can you quote me?

@Qvist:  It doesn't strike you as the least bit odd that EVERYONE thinks CF is scummy?  If Everyone thinks CF is scummy that includes scum.  This could be seen as scum pushing a towny for a mislynch or fingering their scum buddy for some cred.  I would agree that CF looks fishy but I think I want to see a flip before I lynch him as the "everyone thinks CF is scummy" can be seen in more than one way.

Huh? If everyone would think that CF is scummy than we wouldn't be in that position. Eevee and Voltgloss has him at #5 and jotheonah at #6. What I meant was directed at you and ashersky. So I make it more direct as it seemed not understandable.
@TheMunch and ashersky? Why don't you vote for Captain_Frisk? But I don't expect that Captain_Frisk gets killed tonight because beside of us 3 there seem no-one willing to vote for him.

Thats a day 2 quote buddy.

[Qvist]

RL just blew up.  My wife was in a car accident.  Sounds like no one is hurt but I have to go.  I'll respond to collected questions/issues when I am back.

Oh man, I'm sorry for you. I hope she is alright.

[Qvist]

Last thing

So, you just outed TheMunch as Doctor, great pro-town play!

The possibility of Munch being Doctor was already discussed at the very beginning of the thread

So I'm alive... thats fun.

Vote: Captain_Frisk

Sigh....

First I was going to be shocked that you were actually still alive.  I figured you must be the doctor if you hammered without waiting for counter claim, and thus you must be town.

There are however 2 other options:

1. Mafia thought you must be a crazy townie, and then the real doctor will protect you.
2. You are mafia.

You voting for me points toward #1.

I think I might have missed that.

[Qvist]

And hurray I catched up with reading. I took way longer than I thought. I'm not sure if I come back online today. And if I do, I check Pandemic and some other threads first.

[Axxle]

RL just blew up.  My wife was in a car accident.  Sounds like no one is hurt but I have to go.  I'll respond to collected questions/issues when I am back.

hope everyone involved is alright.

[Captain_Frisk]

And hurray I catched up with reading. I took way longer than I thought. I'm not sure if I come back online today. And if I do, I check Pandemic and some other threads first.

Why?

[Voltgloss]

Apparently everyone is physically OK, but my wife is very shaken.  My mother is going there to pick them up now (she's closer than my workplace).  Thanks.

Thats a day 2 quote buddy.

I know.  Qvist asked why I tried to "bandwagon" yuma on Day 2.  I asked Qvist why he tried to "bandwagon" you on Day 2.  He said he didn't.  So I posted the quote.

FYI, my RL emergency is no reason to stop discussing (nor is it for "sympathy points"), just wanted to make clear why I won't be around much for rest of day.

[Voltgloss]

One other q

I just find it hard to believe that he is pushign this hard to keep qvist alive if they are scum buddies if this immediately outs them as scumbuddies.

PPE you dont have to answer my qustion Volt.

Ask yourself this:  if Axxle is town, why is he so sure that Qvist is the Cop and I am the fake?

I have been equally sure and equally wrong in the past?  Confirmation bias?  Take your pick.  But like I said if he is so sure because he is his scum buddy, this would literally lose them the game regardless of whether Qvist is lynched today.  Qvist might be new but Axxle isnt.

[Voltgloss]

well that was a fail let me try that again

[Voltgloss]

Ask yourself this:  if Axxle is town, why is he so sure that Qvist is the Cop and I am the fake?

I have been equally sure and equally wrong in the past?  Confirmation bias?  Take your pick.  But like I said if he is so sure because he is his scum buddy, this would literally lose them the game regardless of whether Qvist is lynched today.  Qvist might be new but Axxle isnt.
[/quote]
[/quote]

Town!Axxle is a lot more careful and cautious than you are Munch.  No offense.

And I think scum!Axxle is trying to WIFOM you.  You said you prefer Ockham's Razor to WIFOM, and that's the right approach.  If I'm lynched, when I flip town, you will have one 100% confirmed scum (Qvist) and one other player (Axxle) who did everything in his power to prevent confirmed scum's lynch, at a time when if confirmed scum was lynched, scum would lose.  Apply Ockham's Razor.

[Voltgloss]

vote: quote tags

(not a serious vote)

My content above is after the failed quote tags.

[Captain_Frisk]

vote: quote tags

(not a serious vote)

My content above is after the failed quote tags.

Dude - go deal with your wife?

[Voltgloss]

vote: quote tags

(not a serious vote)

My content above is after the failed quote tags.

Dude - go deal with your wife?

I have to finish a filing due today before I can leave the office.  Yes, it sucks.

[Axxle]

Town!Axxle is a lot more careful and cautious than you are Munch.  No offense.

And I think scum!Axxle is trying to WIFOM you.  You said you prefer Ockham's Razor to WIFOM, and that's the right approach.  If I'm lynched, when I flip town, you will have one 100% confirmed scum (Qvist) and one other player (Axxle) who did everything in his power to prevent confirmed scum's lynch, at a time when if confirmed scum was lynched, scum would lose.  Apply Ockham's Razor.

I've been becoming increasingly confident in my reads, just see XIII where I called Ogre town pretty heavy handedly.

[Captain_Frisk]

@themunch - its the final play of the game, you have to make a pick.. yOU have 10 seconds - who is your scumteam?

No Seriously.

VG/Ash but I'm very uncomfortable about who VG's scumbuddy is.

So what has changed your mind, given that you were ready to vote qvist last night?

TheMunch - you still haven't answered this.

[Captain_Frisk]

And where is ashersky?

[Axxle]

Vote: Voltgloss

I haven't seen anything that makes me even close to changing my mind on this yet.

[Captain_Frisk]

Vote: Voltgloss

I haven't seen anything that makes me even close to changing my mind on this yet.

What is that vote accomplishing?

[Axxle]

What is no vote accomplishing?

[Captain_Frisk]

What is no vote accomplishing?

Further time to discuss?  Wouldn't you like to grill Asher some more? 

[Captain_Frisk]

What is no vote accomplishing?

Further time to discuss?  Wouldn't you like to grill Asher some more?

Lets say you're wrong.  You know that we'll all go crazy and lynch you tomorrow right?  Game over you've just lost the game - REGARDLESS OF YOUR ALIGNMENT

[Axxle]

What is no vote accomplishing?

Further time to discuss?  Wouldn't you like to grill Asher some more?

Lets say you're wrong.  You know that we'll all go crazy and lynch you tomorrow right?  Game over you've just lost the game - REGARDLESS OF YOUR ALIGNMENT

But if I'm right we win.

And this would happen regardless of when we lynch Voltgloss. 

[Axxle]

Unvote

Actually, I might consider allowing a lynch of QVist today as if I am wrong mislynching me wouldn't end the game.

[Captain_Frisk]

What is no vote accomplishing?

Further time to discuss?  Wouldn't you like to grill Asher some more?

Lets say you're wrong.  You know that we'll all go crazy and lynch you tomorrow right?  Game over you've just lost the game - REGARDLESS OF YOUR ALIGNMENT

But if I'm right we win.

And this would happen regardless of when we lynch Voltgloss.

Wait - how do we win?  Walk me through it.