... yet.
though actually, the deadline is tomorrow. huh. this day feels short.
To me too. No idea why.
So, I'm going to reread Qvist's posts to see whether he deserves to be on L-1 (and whether I should hammer or not)
So, the beginning. First post:
As no one really died in the first night, it's hard to draw conclusions right now. We can now only random vote and wait until somebody slips.
And then he random votes for Hydrad
This is a pretty weird post to me. I really feel like this is a post to discourage too much discussion and just vote, especially because we are playing Newbie Mafia, so maybe someone is gullible and listens to this advice.
This is definitely to early to risk a hammer on Hydrad. Unvote
I agree with Andrew that all the talk about lynching someone who is a veteran player might be strategically reasonable is nonsense. We should just focus in finding out who is mafia and lynch him.
I'm interested in seeing what happens though, so vote: Hydrad and now it's L-2 unless I'm mistaken.
Why should we already test out what happens? Not everybody has even posted here yet. We should wait.
Firstly, and I've said this before, this is a rather strange unvote. Hydrad was a L-2, so no really big deal yet, and this seems really like Qvist is a bit shocked about the votes on Hydrad, and does not want to look scummy.
Besides, again Qvist tries to reduce the discussion and insists on waiting. This is particularly scummy to me, because the scum might be a bit scared of a slip.
Qvist makes a post mainly reacting to others.
Also, he says ADK may be right about me being town.
Then he is in a discussion with Awaclus about Awaclus saying he trusts Qvist. That's towny to me.
After that he is back with his vote on Hydrad.
Vote: Hydrad again because I think we all agreed that we still have enough time to analyze the behaviour and wait for slips, but now he puts (or believe he had put) Andrew at L-1. That's totally unreasonable.
Funnily he seems to have lost his fear of L-2 at this stage, but yeah, that's not really relevant I think.
He then proceeds to attack Hydrad.
He then mentions his reads so far. He suspects Hydrad and Awaclus, and has a town read on all the others.
Also, he says it's day one and he doesn't know very well what to talk about. This is post #298. There has been quite some discussion before this point. Surely there was something to talk about..
He wants to hear a full claim. Can't blame him for that, as I did the same. Still scummy though.
And now comes something quite strange. This post:
Regarding the town slip of Hugo: ADK was pointing it out, twice!
...
This quote is his second time, bold added. It could very well be that ADK and Hugo are a scum team and ADK is indeed the vet who coached Hugo to fake a town slip just to point it out by himself.
Huh? But before you said I was probably town, thanks to ADK pointing this out. I really do not understand where this change came from, or why it has to be made so late on a day. Nobody said this before him. He didn't do a full reread. So where did this come from?
His new conclusion, includes Awaclus and ADK as weak scum reads. That's pretty reasonable.
He has only said something 'today' about being suspicious not voting. Not really interesting.
This all together adds up to a scum read for Qvist from me. But, that's not the most important thing to be said for a Qvist-is-scum-case. It is the way he posts. He often posts one sentence accompanied with a quote. Maybe two. He selects tiny bits of discussion and reacts to them. This is an ideal scum strategy I think. You are saying 'I'm active, look, I've read this post', but at the same time, you're not adding much to the discussion.
Author
Topic: Newbie Mafia 7: Fish Mafia (Game Over - Mafia Wins Flawlessly!) (Read 75001 times)