Okay, when I last posted (like a billion pages ago it seems) I suspected SFS. His contributions since then have me leaning more towards a town read. I feel like Mafia play (even noob Mafia play) would be more calculated.
I feel like this is the point where I should be throwing around a vote, but none of the bandwagons I've seen have really sold me yet. Let's go down the list (by which I mean, everyone whop has votes on them as of the last vote count):
Insomniac:
I'm not certain his jumping on J was just carelessness. But 25 pages is a lot to reread, and especially as he's been involved in MII and MIII, I could see how he could get confused. We all need to be careful to judges people only by the actions they take in this game, or at least keep other games separate. On the other hand, if he were scum he might be trying to join one bandwagon while leaving the other likely bandwagon open for himself, so I see J's point. Right now I'd call him slightly scummy.
Robz888:
I agree with him that one of the Mafia is probably a "pseudo-lurker", since it seems like an easy way for an inexperienced Mafioso to hide (and because it's just statistically likely given the number of Mafia.) Robz himself doesn't read scummy at all to me. He read very scummy to me in MII where he was scum. Of course that doesn't really mean anything, but I haven't seen anything in his posts to convince me he's Mafia.
popsofCtown:
His terse style and refusal to answer questions strikes me as unhelpful. It would be an easy way to play Mafia since the less you talk, the harder it is to catch yourself in a lie. I said before I had suspicions about him, and I still do. I think if I had to vote now, I would vote for him. I would like to hear more from the people who think he's scum. It's more of a gut feeling for me right now than a reasoned analysis and I don't feel like voting based on that at this phase of the game when he already has four votes on him.
Grujah: Given what I said earlier about expecting one of the Mafia to be a pseudolurker, he seems the most likely candidate to me. Again, gut feeling. After this post I might go back and look more closely at his contributions, see if I can find anything odd we might have missed.
jotheonah: SO far his play looks like town play to me, especially seeing as coming off the train wreck that was Mafia II changing up his play style is a sensible move. He looks the tiniest bit scummy to me, but for now I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.
DSell: CF's arguments against him could apply to a lot of people. His vote seemed to come out of no where. DSell hasn't really done much to give me a read on him either way.
Okay, so that's it for me for now. I think I'm going look over Grujah's contributions and see if anything sticks out at me. I might also revisit DSell and Insomniac depending how much time I end up having? We'll see.
btw, I'm now super-paranoid about my posts reading as "fluff" thanks to Robz. If that was your goal, you've accomplished it.