In this game so far, there has been a LOT of material that's looked to me to be suspicious/scummy. It's rather hard to keep track of, actually. So here's a list of some things that have struck me wrong, starting with a list of where I was at yesterday and then an amended list to reflect some things that have happened today.
Yesterday's list:
popsofctown: His style really bothers me and he's been very underwhelming to me in terms of helpfulness. I would have expected more from such an experienced player. Since I really don't get a lot of his posts, I think there is a very real chance that he is using strategies that are way above me, but that doesn't clear him. I would expect town to be at least somewhat helpful, and he has been suppressing information and posts, rather than contributing. I don't at all like being manipulated. (p-p edit: just as I think it's smart to look at his bandwagon, I agree with his recent post that checking jo's bandwagon is a good idea too)
SFS: Tough to know what to make of him, but his dearth of substance has NOT built up any trust with me. I am glad that he has attempted some substance so I am willing to wait things out with him. Even his substance, though, has not made me feel much better. I seriously, seriously have my eye on him.
Grujah: His vote for pops felt the most bandwagony to me. He gave no real reason, but what interests me most is his defense: intentionally bandwagoning and then deflecting attention. Finally, he pointed out that pops was online but not answering answering. He then disappeared himself. I don't know what to make of his activity as a whole, but this series of events struck me as very strange. (p-p edit: also do not like him repeatedly touting how impressionable he is...if nothing else it is a weakness he should not show)
Theorel: Of his minimal content yesterday, what I saw looked copied and pasted from the "how a mafiosa wants to appear" playbook. Not enough to build a case on but enough to pique my interest.
Also minimally suspicious of jo and Axxle.
Updated to reflect more of today's posts:
Theorel: A lot of new posts that seem really straight up. Not suspicious anymore, I think he could be a real asset to the town.
jo: I think that I need to go back and review some more of what's happened since I was reading quickly to try to catch up, but his defense seems almost frantic to me. Chill out man. Also the "I'm mafia" thing. Just bad bad bad bad. More suspicious today, need to go back and review some more though.
pops: What can I say? Both he and SFS are now going against Robz and he is again telling us "we should all just copy him." Why? No! Give me a better reason man! On that note, SFS is now a former poker player? Not sure how this reflects on things but his self-deprecation just got more suspicious to me.