Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[2.71828.....]

Is it just me or are people just voting randomly. Very few votes were made with reasonable explanations. I know this is day 1, but many didn't even bother explaining, just voted.
I will keep my vote at RR because his reaction was way too defensive when he saw the train going and only outed his lurking, that is my reasoning at least.
And as others pointed out, RR should probably claim now, IMHO.

I disagree strongly with anyone being forced into a claim they don't want to make

[Qvist]

Why?

[Galzria]

Don't want to lynch: Eevee, Galzria, RR, e

Will lynch: Everyone else

How do you feel that two of your four are voting for 1 of your four?

I feel weirdly that his list is me and the 3 people I've voted for this game. But I may simply be paranoid and seeing things.

I mean, that is an observation. I don't get what your conclusion is though. WW is the anti-Galzria?

Not everything needs or has a conclusion. It's simply weird to me.

[2.71828.....]

Why?

I trust town to best utilize their own role without is telling them how to do it

[2.71828.....]

Why?

I trust town to best utilize their own role without is telling them how to do it

And when we disagree with a certain application of a role..... well, we can learn something from that

[Witherweaver]

Is it just me or are people just voting randomly. Very few votes were made with reasonable explanations. I know this is day 1, but many didn't even bother explaining, just voted.
I will keep my vote at RR because his reaction was way too defensive when he saw the train going and only outed his lurking, that is my reasoning at least.
And as others pointed out, RR should probably claim now, IMHO.

It depends on whether you prescribe to the hidden variable theory of Mafia or not.

[Witherweaver]

Don't want to lynch: Eevee, Galzria, RR, e

Will lynch: Everyone else

How do you feel that two of your four are voting for 1 of your four?

I feel weirdly that his list is me and the 3 people I've voted for this game. But I may simply be paranoid and seeing things.

I mean, that is an observation. I don't get what your conclusion is though. WW is the anti-Galzria?

Not everything needs or has a conclusion. It's simply weird to me.

The conclusion is obviously that you're wrong~

[faust]

So. RR.

I feel like I am fairly good at reading him. I forget which game it was (like 10-15 games ago, more? I don't know) but we had this little mini conversation between us about how well I read RR. That was another game he was town and ultimately got lynched (pretty sure).

Anyway, this feels a lot like that. RR is being town!RR here. Call it gut, call it whatever. But he is town here (just wait for me to flip on you at EoD like I did to CJ last game).

But yeah. I can go back and look at specific posts if you want, but every post I call a town tell someone else can interpret it as scum. D1 without any results comes down to gut most of the time. And RR is town

Hm. Do you have evidence showing how good you are at reading him?

[Qvist]

Is it just me or are people just voting randomly. Very few votes were made with reasonable explanations. I know this is day 1, but many didn't even bother explaining, just voted.
I will keep my vote at RR because his reaction was way too defensive when he saw the train going and only outed his lurking, that is my reasoning at least.
And as others pointed out, RR should probably claim now, IMHO.

It depends on whether you prescribe to the hidden variable theory of Mafia or not.

Not sure what that means.

[Roadrunner7671]

I actually think e's not too bad at reading me.

But I'm not gonna claim because despite my wagon and stuff, I'd be shocked if I got lynched.

[O]

Is it just me or are people just voting randomly. Very few votes were made with reasonable explanations. I know this is day 1, but many didn't even bother explaining, just voted.

it's mostly a pro-personal meta anti-town meta thing the young whippersnappers (and Galzria apparently) are doing these days. If you never provide reasons for voting the only analysis of whether you're town/scum is who you actually voted for.

[Eevee]

Reread RR.

I'm on the fence, still. Those long posts read to me more like scum paranoia than anything else, but the other posts felt townier to me.

Unvote I guess.

[Eevee]

Vote: O

O seems to be following the path of least resistance here. It's not much, but I think scumO would play something like this.

[Robz888]

Reminder: Dharma open mic night starts in an hour. Feel free to sit in any empty chair. Well, except that empty chair.

Vote Count 1.8

LaLight (1): Jimmmmm
gkrieg13 (3): 2.71828, SpaceAnemone, LaLight
RoadRunner7671 (4): Qvist, DatSwan, faust, Archetype
O (2): Witherweaver, Eevee
Eevee (1): gkrieg13
DatSwan (2): RoadRunner7671, iguaniguana
Witherweaver (2): O, Teproc

Not Voting (2): IDontPlayThisGame, Galzria

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch. Day 1 ends Monday, September 25th, at 2:00 PM. Godspeed.

[O]

Vote: O

O seems to be following the path of least resistance here. It's not much, but I think scumO would play something like this.

It's not the path of least resistance, it's that the current wagons are god awful.

I am 100% serious about lynching WW.

[Galzria]

Vote: O

O seems to be following the path of least resistance here. It's not much, but I think scumO would play something like this.

It's not the path of least resistance, it's that the current wagons are god awful.

I am 100% serious about lynching WW.

I still like an Eevee lynch. I'm less inclined towards RR now. I want to go back and reread 105 though just to see how he reacted prior to our lynching him... but I feel more townie than scummy on his response here atm.

I would happily support a vote: WW lynch though. You're reading townie to me and I don't have any hesitancy sheeping you.

[O]

Vote: O

O seems to be following the path of least resistance here. It's not much, but I think scumO would play something like this.

It's not the path of least resistance, it's that the current wagons are god awful.

I am 100% serious about lynching WW.

I still like an Eevee lynch. I'm less inclined towards RR now. I want to go back and reread 105 though just to see how he reacted prior to our lynching him... but I feel more townie than scummy on his response here atm.

I would happily support a vote: WW lynch though. You're reading townie to me and I don't have any hesitancy sheeping you.

I'm not convinced after I vote Eevee --> Eevee responds --> I back off that scum!eevee would poke me again

[gkrieg13]

vote: WW

[Galzria]

Possibly. But his posts are so few (admission of intent is... weird. From both scum and town), and really, really lack in content. Plus - if you believe in these things - there was a Freudian slip where he admitted to being scum.

seems i can't even fakeclaim town right, maybe that'll make you trust me.

spider senses indicate swan = town.

[Galzria]

Or I'm just misreading that.

[Eevee]

Vote: WW

I think reminding us to suspect the poisoner is scummy, as keeping that suspicion alive is very much in scum's interest if Iguana is town (which is the more likely scenario). WW seems to be playing it pretty safe as well, I'm buying what O is selling here.

[Witherweaver]

I don't see how what I'm doing is playing it safe.

[Eevee]

Or I'm just misreading that.

It was a joke that I couldn't even get the fake town claim for a secondary win condition down correctly, "haha look I can't lie".

[Eevee]

I don't see how what I'm doing is playing it safe.

I just mean it's a very standard WW day of mafia. Active, but not a leader figure. Some votes, some town reads, some jokes, some serious analysis, nothing that's too far out of line.

Scum is polished, knows to avoid the pitfalls. I think this is what scumWW would look like.

[Witherweaver]

I don't see how what I'm doing is playing it safe.

I just mean it's a very standard WW day of mafia. Active, but not a leader figure. Some votes, some town reads, some jokes, some serious analysis, nothing that's too far out of line.

Scum is polished, knows to avoid the pitfalls. I think this is what scumWW would look like.

And what is it you think that town!WW would look like?