I could potentially be convinced to add Jack into a coalition of some sort if we want to try including the less active players
I think Jack is towny too. Swap Jack for Mix?
Robz/joth are you willing to consider the list that’s currently in the majority?
Ultimately yes. But it’s only in the majority by one vote. I’m more likely to switch to the other competing wagon.
Meaning you think MiX is more likely to be town than I am?
Not really. Maybe marginally. It’s more that I think it’s more interesting to give people equal choices than to contribute to a sort of fait accompli by moving big wagon from 3 to 4.
Let’s do it.
Remove: Eevee, Cuzz
Add: MiX, Awaclus
I think either you are scum or you are just thinking about this game in a way that I really disagree with. The goal of the coalition is to put 5 townies in it and then we win the game, but instead of basing your choices directly on who you think is town you’re doing this weird higher level meta
game stuff.
I still lean town on you because of townie seeming interactions from earlier which is frustrating because I’m tempted to take you off my list but first I’m curious if anyone else has opinions about this.
But like… what are you basing your reads on? There hasn’t been enough posting, play, or interaction for me to trust my reads at all. But what I do know is that scum has a goal here and it’s rather more urgent than town’s goal. If this were a winning coalition, I would expect to see resistance against it and I don’t. Of course I know what follows from that if you haven’t seen my role PM: I am providing that resistance, ergo I’m scum by my own argument. I don’t really know how to get out of that particular intellectual pincer movement. But what I do know is the path of least resistance seems unlikely to succeed.
Remove: everyone
Add: Awaclus
Add: mcmc
Add: Robz
Add: Cuzz
Add: MiX
Anyone up for this coalition?
Robz/joth are you willing to consider the list that’s currently in the majority?
I think a list that includes myself, Robz, mcmc, and Cuzz is very likely to contain scum. Because if we’re all town, what exactly is scum doing right now? Sitting back and letting us sort things out? I don’t think that’s 5-dimensional chess, it’s just common sense.
Robz you posted: Robz, mcmc, joth, eevee, cuzz
I like the : (Robz, mcmc, joth) part and offered to add eevee who I think you can read well you add mix, with the idea I can read Mix well
You respond by saying you agree with my theory and in practice but you cant read mix well.
Then Joth posts: Robz, Joth, Eevee, Mix, Awaclus which is the same as my group but subs out me for awaclus.
And you like that list but sub eevee out for me and post: Robz, Joth, Mcmc, Mix, Awaclus.
So based on that you are now good with including mix but no longer want to include eevee??
Yep. The double ?? suggests incredulity but you accurately described my thought process!
Then could you elaborate. What changed your mind on including Mix and why did you take out eevee?
I don't have a townread on him, but I added him to my coalition because he's more active and thus possibly easier to read than the somewhat unknown (to me at least) quantities.
Every part of this sentence seems false to me.
Well it's the truth.
The truth is that you don’t have a read on him but you’re including him because he’s easy to read?
I don't have a townread on him, but I added him to my coalition because he's more active and thus possibly easier to read than the somewhat unknown (to me at least) quantities.
Every part of this sentence seems false to me.
Robz you posted: Robz, mcmc, joth, eevee, cuzz
I like the : (Robz, mcmc, joth) part and offered to add eevee who I think you can read well you add mix, with the idea I can read Mix well
You respond by saying you agree with my theory and in practice but you cant read mix well.
Then Joth posts: Robz, Joth, Eevee, Mix, Awaclus which is the same as my group but subs out me for awaclus.
And you like that list but sub eevee out for me and post: Robz, Joth, Mcmc, Mix, Awaclus.
So based on that you are now good with including mix but no longer want to include eevee??
Add: Awaclus
Add: MiX
Full list:
Joth
Robz
Eevee
Awaclus
MiX
This is where I’d like to be for now.
I’d like to hear more from Jack and scolapasta.
Robz what did you think about my post for a me, you, joth, eevee, mix coalition?
One of these things happened
Option A
I went back to post#1 to re-read the setup and caught day chat in the mafia pm with my eagle eyes
Option B
I've been chatting away with my partner in the mafia thread all this time and decided to bring it up for town cred.
Who thinks A/B?
That's partly why I'm not too bothered about speculating about this out loud. I guarantee scum is having these conversations, so we may as well have them out in the open here so that everyone is equally aware of the game. Also, it's something to talk about.
Can you vote for yourself for the coalition?yes.
If we randomly chose a group of five people, like using random.org, which might not be allowed but that's beside the point, we'd expect to win the game one time in six, if I've done the math right. Which it's entirely possible I haven't.
