I know poker TV shows are post-commentated (the announcers are, at least) but you can also hear the players chatting at the tables as well. I imagine if there was a way to hear the players' thoughts on poker shows, it would provide a ton of insight, but hey, we have that ability... sort of.
My strategy isn't always completely formulated at the beginning of the game, and I believe there is something to be gained from hearing comments in-game, but I don't think you're talking about getting rid of that, no?
Watching these pairs of videos that were posted today, I felt like they were very similar. The back-and-forth banter, which makes up maybe 70-80% of the commentary is the same on both videos, so it might make sense to combine the two into one video. Is this what you're getting at?
Issues with that:
- We need a way to see both players' hands at once, and a readable game log along with that at the very least. I'm not sure how to accomplish this.
- At the beginning (and any other time when both of us are talking to our videos at the same time) we need a way to hear those audios separately, which will require some video/audio editing (pause the video and insert commentary that isn't in real-time, and somehow denote that with a visual cue). I could do this with my current software, though it's not exactly straight-forward. Is this what you're talking about?
I don't know how much I could add in about my games through post-commentary. Usually I make an effort to talk for a few minutes about the game at the end with my opponent -- are you suggesting something different than this?