I'm still confused why Andrew living has any bearing on my alignment.
I'm pretty sure one of the strongest ever claimed town PRs in the history of f.ds surviving when presumably he can't self doctor AND two other people died is a strong argument that ANDREW is scum, and that my original read was right.
His doc/block claim could just as easily be a scum Roleblocker cover.
I disagree. Twofold reasons...
1. he was a mislynch option yesterday, that isn't going to just magically go away. Scum want to leave alive mislynch options if at all possible
2. I still contend that scum is going to kill people who they think the least likely to be protected or watched or whatever in this situation... I would put Andrew pretty high on the list of "likely to be protected or watched" and thus a bad kill for today, especially in RMM where everyone is going to have a role of some sort. If I were a protective role or a watcher I think Andrew would have been high on my list
and yes I realize that my reasons above somewhat contradict, but that just amplifies the problem that scum has with killing him, lots of WIFOM. Scum doesn't want to mess around with WIFOM for their night kills... they want to make sure they go through and that they don't get caught doing it!
And we don't even know what roles mafia has, maybe they just bussed andrew or something akin to that.
Regardless he is still a top townread and we shouldn't be lynching him today.