I was expecting yuma to be targeted for a NK and maybe doctored but I guess with two NKs he probably wasn't even targeted? Or is there a good reason scum wouldn't target yuma for a NKS?
Here's the post everyone and their mother picked up on. As I've mentioned, I see two narratives where this makes sense:
1) Andrew is not lying about his role. That means he most likely doctored yuma, and then was surprised that anyone, let alone two players, died. This would be consistent with a newbie player who's also never played RMM, since anyone who has would know that there are many ways for players to die, get around doctoring, etc.
2) Andrew is lying about his role. That means he's most likely scum, and he was trying to make a statement that would be consistent with his fakeclaim while showing town!concern. This would be consistent with a newbie player who's never played scum before or RMM before, since this is a bit of a fumble. We've seen it happen to newbie scum before.
Both of these narratives are possible, and in a vacuum I'd say the town narrative is more likely. We don't play these games in a vacuum, though. Taking into account his super scummy D1, his survival after his claim, and his current defensiveness, I am leaning scum again on Andrew, and am kicking myself for falling for his crap near the end of D1 that forced us into the sudgy mislynch.