Okay, so I think I need to figure out my actual reads again. I'm having trouble keeping track. Okay, let's try something a little different this time. I'm going to list all players, and try to sort them from scummiest read to towniest.
nkirbit - I dunno, his posts seem not genuine somehow? I mean before with the quasi-defense of sudgy, and now with the vote essentially for defending himself. I disagree substantively with the idea that town is more likely to present "better" alternatives, I think that's more likely to be scum (see mail-mi in XXX where he suggests Robz as a "better" alternative as an example). Town is more likely to get stuck on their own "towniness", while scum really just wants someone else lynched.
Eevee - There's just not a lot to go on this game. This day has gone so strangely, that I have no good "action-analysis". i.e. there's no apparent way that scum are trying to control the game, unless they're really seeking to get sudgy lynched...but that doesn't fit with a scum-narrative. So, we end up with the relatively minor Eevee-finds-people-scummy case, as really one of the more compelling cases. Funny, given that I just gave an example of where it wasn't true.
mail-mi - I looked into the lurking thing. It seems like it's not a scum-tell, given that he has had middling-low post counts as both town and scum before. He tends to be a low-end poster, but not absent. I'm willing to admit that I just got lucky in MXXX.
sudgy - I dunno, I'm more convinced he'll be flipping town. But we're in this weird case of alternatives all being quickly rejected as the sudgy wagon builds up again. I just don't see sudgy as scummy enough to be the default-lynch. I mean, I don't think he's super-townie...I dunno. I'll vote here to ensure a lynch if it's needed, but I just don't get the fervor about it.
And, I'm not explaining the rest of these, I think they're all explained elsewhere if you're curious.
twistedarcher
yuma
xerxes
chairs
Robz
ashersky
Voltaire
Galzria
Well, I just offered a counter-example for Eevee being scum. Although it seems like there's more support there, I'm going to vote: nkirbit first, to see if there's any unspoken support there.