Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[nkirbit]

Vote: spiritbears, for obvious reasons.

Do you think he's scum, or are you just voting because he didn't answer the question?

[spiritbears]

You make me laugh Robz!

[yuma]

well for me he (sb) has participated. An "I don't know" to me is a completely acceptable answer. And is just as full of analysis potential as any other answer. For me scummy play would be to ignore the question completely and avoid talking about it at all. Something sb has not done. Rather he has done the opposite.

So while I don't like his answer, I respect it and feel inclined to move on, but I am guessing some parts of town won't want to.

[mail-mi]

So while I don't like his answer, I respect it and feel inclined to move on, but I am guessing some parts of town won't want to.

I do. I think that this is all going to end up as a bunch of WIFOM stuff, but other's dont.

[sudgy]

So while I don't like his answer, I respect it and feel inclined to move on, but I am guessing some parts of town won't want to.

I do. I think that this is all going to end up as a bunch of WIFOM stuff, but other's dont.

I agree with this, but it still could help.  And, of course, it's made for a lot of discussion.

[mail-mi]

So while I don't like his answer, I respect it and feel inclined to move on, but I am guessing some parts of town won't want to.

I do. I think that this is all going to end up as a bunch of WIFOM stuff, but other's dont.

I agree with this, but it still could help.  And, of course, it's made for a lot of discussion.

True, true.

[spiritbears]

Have we heard from all the  kids here yet? Seems like we are missing a few...

[Kooshie]

Vote Count 1.3

Eevee (1): nkirbit
Robz (3): yuma, sudgy, modestguineapig
Ashersky (3): spiritbears, mail-mi, Eevee
spiritbears (1): Robz

Not voting: liopoil, mcmcsalot, Ahoppy, ashersky
With 12 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch

[liopoil]

Have we heard from all the  kids here yet? Seems like we are missing a few...

everyone has posted

[spiritbears]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

[yuma]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

Not much of a case but the scummiest thing I have seen thus far...

I didn't even realize the scum were picking their partners. Fascinating.

How did you not realize this? What did you think those three PMs were all about then? You know the ones that you had to keep confirming?

Does anyone else find this post odd? Especially after this post:

So, this game is at first glance rather daunting. We have no idea what PRs are in effect.

Where it is apparent that Robz had read through the game setup because he knows we don't know what PRs are in the game.

vote: Robz

He hasn't done anything else to make me think him more town or more scum at this point that I can remember. His vote on you has not impacted my vote on him.... although I did just notice this, a complete double take on you, not sure how scummy it is, but worth noting...

Ashersky is correct, spiritbears. Scum always have a qt.

I very much doubt that this was anything other than a mistake though, ash. In fact, I think it's a genuine mistake, which means he has no knowledge that scum have a qt. What does that make him? Town. He's town, you retaliator!

Vote: spiritbears, for obvious reasons.

Oh and I didn't take his vote on you as a joke. Robz doesn't do RVS...

[Robz888]

I wasn't joking! He refused to answer a question. I'm not going to excuse poor behavior.

(I chose to leave it ambiguous whether it was a joke, because on wanted to gauge how he--and others--reacted to it.)

[liopoil]

I do not find spiritbears scummy. I disagree with him not answering the question (although, really, he did answer it by saying he has no clue who he would pick, which is good enough for me). I don't agree with his read on ashersky either, but I see no reason to find him scummy for it.

[ashersky]

Robz doesn't do RVS...

It does stand for Robz Voting Stage, usually...

[ashersky]

I do not find spiritbears scummy. I disagree with him not answering the question (although, really, he did answer it by saying he has no clue who he would pick, which is good enough for me). I don't agree with his read on ashersky either, but I see no reason to find him scummy for it.

I think his adamant stance on not answering the question is anti-town.  Anti-town doesn't = scummy, though.  And, I really don't see scum adamantly refusing to answer a question that is clearly pro-town, since that brings unwanted attention on them.

Now, if sb is scum, he may think he's protecting his buddies by not providing the wifom option for this list.  But if he's scum, I think he's hurting his team by making himself stick out so much.

So, most likely, this action is not the action of mafia.

[liopoil]

Robz doesn't do RVS...

It does stand for Robz Voting Stage, usually...

if robz did RVS, then Yuma would also do RVS, then suddenly we're just 5 RVS votes away from RLS!

(R=robz L=lynching)

I do not find spiritbears scummy. I disagree with him not answering the question (although, really, he did answer it by saying he has no clue who he would pick, which is good enough for me). I don't agree with his read on ashersky either, but I see no reason to find him scummy for it.

I think his adamant stance on not answering the question is anti-town.  Anti-town doesn't = scummy, though.

That's pretty much what I meant, yeah.

[nkirbit]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

Why do you want Yuma's case, as opposed to anyone elses?  How do you know Yuma isn't scum?

[ashersky]

yuma: ashersky, mcmc/lio
ashersky: Eevee, mail-mi/lio
mail-mi: yuma, newbie
Eevee: mcmc, mgp
liopoil: Eevee, mgp
Robz888: liopoil
nkirbit: random, being new
AHoppy: random, based on iso ranking
modestguineapig: Eevee, AHoppy
mcmcsalot: Robz, Eevee (or ash/sb)
spiritbears: Refuse to answer
sudgy: mail-mi, yuma



Total Mentions:
4: Eevee
3: liopoil
2: yuma, ashesrky, mail-mi, mgp, mcmc
1: robz, ahoppy, sb
0: nkirbit, sudgy



I don't know what to glean from this, but there it is.

[ashersky]

at least there is nothing to mass (flavor or role or map) claim this time

Theoretical partners claiming happened.  So pbbt.

Seriously though, I think given the "regular" nature of this game, we're better off this way.  This isn't LOTR where race claims can make a difference and sudgy can claim Eagle.

I think we take the mods at their word when they described this as mostly vanilla and focus on scumhunting, not set-up solving.

[liopoil]

it means that since I'm not scum eevee probably is

[spiritbears]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

Why do you want Yuma's case, as opposed to anyone elses?  How do you know Yuma isn't scum?

I think Yuma is probably a safe town read, and I remembered he was on robz early...likely for a good reason
Together with his flip on me that's enough for me to join the wagon
vote:robz

[Eevee]

I guess this is an honor of sorts? Not scum though, please don't lynch me!

spirit, I think you are trusting yuma a little too much. Now,  I don't disagree with your conclusion, the Robz case is better than anything we've seen yet (well, I acknowledge the merit on the "case" against me in that apparently people would pick me / at least they say they would pick me). It's wifom though, in would scum name their partner? Maybe this actually clears me and liopoil a bit?

I seem to be rambling, sleepy time.

[nkirbit]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

Why do you want Yuma's case, as opposed to anyone elses?  How do you know Yuma isn't scum?

I think Yuma is probably a safe town read, and I remembered he was on robz early...likely for a good reason
Together with his flip on me that's enough for me to join the wagon
vote:robz

What's your reasoning for this read?  It's not one I share (I'm extremely neutral on Yuma atm)

[spiritbears]

I guess this is an honor of sorts? Not scum though, please don't lynch me!

spirit, I think you are trusting yuma a little too much. Now,  I don't disagree with your conclusion, the Robz case is better than anything we've seen yet (well, I acknowledge the merit on the "case" against me in that apparently people would pick me / at least they say they would pick me). It's wifom though, in would scum name their partner? Maybe this actually clears me and liopoil a bit?

I seem to be rambling, sleepy time.

Maybe I am.  But I don't think so.  All I'm saying is his case + the robz switch on me are good enough for me to join the wagon. I do have a town read on him, but I'm always willing to listen to a reasonable case.

[spiritbears]

Ok. But I unvoted kooshie

Also, Yuma can you give me your quick case on robz. I can't tell if his "obivote" on me was just humor (how I took it) or a quick dirty scum hit without any reason at all

Why do you want Yuma's case, as opposed to anyone elses?  How do you know Yuma isn't scum?

I think Yuma is probably a safe town read, and I remembered he was on robz early...likely for a good reason
Together with his flip on me that's enough for me to join the wagon
vote:robz

What's your reasoning for this read?  It's not one I share (I'm extremely neutral on Yuma atm)

HE's been pretty active and active with a purpose....scum hunting imo
I haven't seen anything from him I would label as scummy at all.  Are you saying I missed something?