Ok - time to kickstart this mother
The Galzwagon
Captain_Frisk, eHunt, Galzria, Jotheonah, TheMunch, Yuma
Off the wagon
QVist, Axxle, Eevee, Voltgloss, ashersky
We have 3 scum - so 4 permutations
A: 3 on the wagon (lynch on the wagon would hit scum with 75%, lynch off the wagon would hit with 0%)
B: 2 on the wagon, 1 off (50%, 20%)
C: 1 on the wagon, 2 off (25%, 40%)
D: 3 off the wagon, (0%, 60%)
My gut says that the night kill of eHunt indicates that more scum were off the wagon than on it, since you're inherently scummier for attempting to lynch non-mafia, so I suspect permutation C or D.
Thus, I'm taking a harder look at:
QVist, Axxle, Eevee, Voltgloss, ashersky
QVist
22 posts thus far. Day 1 he random voted for a bunch of folks (i think 5), but not eHunt or Galz. He's been tunnelling on me day 2. His control of English seems much stronger on day 2. Townread because I don't see new scum being so free with votes on day 1 and risk pissing people off.
Axxle
23 posts thus far. #141 reads like picking on ashersky to me, which I consider to be akin to morgrim hunting.
#180, #181 pick on me for good reason (not seeing that ensuring that the SK knew optimal strategy made sense - but I just mistakenly assumed that random flipping was obv. best strategy for SK). His post count is average, but his content is very weak. Many of his posts are one liners with no content. (See 197, 198, or #163 - my favorite). If it were deadline and I had the hammer, i'd hit it.
Eevee
Now i can talk about how Eevee is my former scum buddy (see RMM3), so I've seen firsthand his scumplay, and I've been in games where he's been town.
#94 - Defending galz from rvs attack
votes joth for no reason - claims it isn't rvs
#142 - defending ehunt despite no pressure (#149)
#268 - posts WTF after thread lock
Did not participate in theory talk on day 1. When he posts, it was primarily to defend people (aka making friends - one with confirmed townie). I'm thinking: Scumeevee.
Day 2: #288 - starts buddying me. #298 - buddies yuma
#324/325 - Telling us to slow down. 0 town points for this, because its obvious protown. I've done the same thing (as scum)
#354: no suspects... light fos on joth and qvist
#386 - starts fighting with the munch - who thinks he's found a scum trio
#389 - thinks munch is town - wants to lynch him anyway
#402 - says we should look @ joth / qvist / axxle / asher. Makes sense because he's already cleared half the players (me, yuma, munch, himself) the only person not mentioned here is voltgloss.
Voltgloss / Grujah
Grujah said nothing meaningful. Volt has pushed hard for a yuma lynch. Has been active scumhunting.
Ashersky
#189 accuses me of deflecting to Galz - which is straight up false (since I had already been pushing on Galz since RVS)
#272 - drops a way late vote well past thread lock
#287 - tries to start up my wagon
yuma calls him out on this craziness in #296
#314 - gives up on my wagon - joins yuma's
If I had to pick a scumteam here, it would be eevee + ashersky, probably with a joth kicker - but picking scumteams is stupid.
I'm happy with my vote. Go reread eevee from the perspective of scum trying not to ruffle feathers and suck up to town.