I can see town making that mistake, but I see scum making that mistake more often than town. Lashing out doesn't do much good. I've seen scum lynched for slips like that, and (fewer) town lynched for similar slips. They happen, and they're decent material to work with. Scum tend to know "what's going on" less in general, and it can be a helpful rule of thumb (that's largely empirical, I can't very strongly explain why).
I've made a post saying O is scummy before, I expressed that I did not like how he did not take a side day 1 amongst the leading wagons and instead just camped out a vote on me. And then Day 2 he criticized the mislynch, as if his lack of participation in actually stringing people up was deliberate. He also just has been largely useless, like table says. He posts forgettably, he doesn't make a lot of posts that have me remembering "oh that guy is looking for scum". The best thing I ever think about his posts is "this guy has a funky anti-town playstyle and I don't think I'll be able to do much to read him", which is an information vacuum that this slip expands to fill.
I just find it hard to believe that this analysis is what you truly believe; primarily because your play style is so similar to mine, except without the humor.
@ your other accusations.
I parked my vote on you because I liked the idea of lynching you and
because I knew I had no control over the D1 lynch anyways. Its my selfish playstyle, and this argument works whether I'm scum or town I know, but I like not being a major factor of the D1 bandwagon because I inherently get more information when I'm not in the wagon then when I am. Mafia I with Theory vs. TINAS was different; I was damn sure TINAS was townie (though I do not claim to know that he was a power role).
I don't remember "criticizing" the misslynch and don't really want to look back 100 pages, if you could bring me that quote I would love to refute that aswell.
And you just admitted you found Tables scummy postwise. I'm not as pro as you are or I'm just too damn lazy, and I just didn't remember.
Final argument before I get myself lynched because survivalist tell is scumtell... I was in Hawaii. I was in MIII (which took a LOT more of my attention as we were in lylo and had much more information), obviously am in MIV, and now MV. I was thinking about posting the sign-ups for MVI. Its not unreasonable that I forget things in one of the mafia games. (Part of the reason I'm hosting MVI is so I don't play in it...
)