@Theorel:
I believe all 5 of us are fair game, as our votes did pile on quickly. If there is anything in particular you would like me to address, please ask, otherwise I don't wish to get into a debate about innocence, since everybody can and will argue from this position. Me saying "but I'm town!" Doesn't help - So direct me to help you! Otherwise I stand by my reasonings to date.
On the others:
Grujah - I didn't like him bandwagon'ing just for the sake of bandwagoning. But it's do blatantly anti-mafia to do so... I just don't know. His posts give some substance, but not much, and his self proclaimed impressionable nature is alarming. Watching, but nothing serious yet.
O - I admit, I don't know if I could tell Mafia O from Town O. It's good for him if he's Mafia, and probably bad for us if he's town, though not necessarily. It's certainly bad for ME, but I'm working on it.
Insomniac - He's appeared honest, but perhaps too much so. Reminds me of me in M-II. Not convinced of innocence, but at my own peril, leaning town.
Axxle - I've been here this game a few times. He was jumpy earlier about being called out, left, and when he came back, was much more mellow. Still suspect him, watching closely.
On Pops - Still strongly suspect, more than the others, for his very erratic, stubborn, unhelpful play. But I don't trust bandwagons, so am backing off for now.
On Jotheonah - I don't believe he ever had anything concrete against him in the past, but he was jumpy at suspicions of him early on. His response to me of "you came after me last time, and got yourself lynched. That worked out well for you didn't it?" Seems like a huge redirect and empty threat to put me off his case.
Anything else I can help you with?