I don't think math's investigative ability caught scum. I'm willing to be convinced otherwise though.
Although we don't actually know if he used his power, or whether he used it on me. (And whatever he did, once a bandwagon starts forming on him, he's going to try to direct people to the other bandwagon if he can.)
I feel like my point is being missed here. Let me clarify...
Vote: GkriegIn regards to Math:
1. They are flipped Cylon Extremist Yellow People.
2. They had an investigative role we know nothing about. Could be Jack is skum from it, could be a complete lie. Who the hell knows right? Ok... That leaves us with the following options:
2a) Math had an ability to cop other skum, was not lying - I find this unlikely given their huge hedge on not knowing if it was alignment vs town. I do agree with mix here in regards to the whole "if they had a skum result they would go all out", because the only reason for them to hedge would be to set up a defense for the next day when they knew if they got their way that Jack would pretty much have to flip Town.
2b) Math had an ability to cop other skum, they were lying (meaning Jack is Town) - I find this more likely then 2a).
2c) Math was full of shit. Couldn't do any of that. - yep. totally could be a thing. Honestly, probably tied for most likely.
Aight, then we got GK:
1. Open with the result/vote for Math.
2. Doesn't know exactly what it means. Honestly that part doesn't matter... Town or skum they end up on Math either way there I think.
3. Math flips Cylon Yellow People.
4. GK opens today saying Math could of had a real result on a different skum team and votes for Jack.
Ok then take that, rabbit hole it with me for a sec...
The only reason GK was towny at first was prior to the thought of there being multiple skum teams (which I get we don't actually know is a thing, but still)... If we factor it in, the way GK is playing is like, at least for me, is crazy suspicious.
Town cop outs the result absolute start of Day 1 (not copping mind you, unsure of what it means).
Then the exile goes off on the person that they copped, and they open the next day with the assumption that "the other bad guys" got caught and start pushing a wagon on Jack.
What happens when we flip Jack? Either they are Town ... or what? GK is town, caught Skum A, and skum A actually caught Skum B that same night??
Or, more likely IMO... GK is potentially skum. They were the one that copped other skum. They use that info in order to further pursue lynches that they can back themselves out of. Keeping in mind ofc, if we were to exile Jack and they did not flip skum, we would have nothing to hold against GK in all of this.