Wow, it's too quiet in here! Is everyone just waiting for Paco's promised re-reads on Sunday or something?
I'm going to read over J Reggie again, since I still feel like there's a good chance he's not as innocent as Paco was insisting he was last time I tried making a case.
#68 His first game post is a vote for Paco.
#96 Votes Ash, and also townreads Paco for the thing he'd voted him for earlier.
#248 Day pass for Zigaton -- seems townie, especially in retrospect.
#253 Votes zigaton.
#273 Unvotes.
#294: "I guess I could see a McGarnacle-zigaton scum team."
#298 On board with Ash's Rolecop plan, which sounds good, but then scum would already have known there wasn't one in the game anyway!
#313: "Also as far as doing stuff, I just proposed a possible scum team." (McGarnacle-Zigaton, at #294).
#324 Puts McGarnacle up to L-1.
#339 FH on McGarnacle. This is where all his town points seem to come from, but it's only one post.
#365: "Ash is scum and has a plan for his partner to claim."
#374 unvotes after McGarnacle claims.
#395 votes RR (taking #2 spot on the wagon).
#406 agrees with Ash about disagreeing with my JR case, but downplays the extent to which he's willing to agree I'm town.
#413 "Sounds like he's soft claiming, so let's not prod any further." -- which LL immediately suggests JR should not have said. Not very townie on JR's part.
#477 "I'm not sure about this recent stuff from PPS. I think I want RR to flip so we can analyze it." Is this the first time JR's mentioned PPS all game?
#465 Starts D2 with a vote for Ash.
#472 Jumps on PPS as soon as LL points out the slip. Could be trying to bus, though.
#478: "PPS is bad at reading setups but his reaction is scummy." -- but that didn't stop him jumping directly on the wagon anyway.
#538: Points out PPS wifom, claims IC yet again, suggests Ash is most likely PPS's buddy.
#557: "I definitely voted for PPS. Also I'm town, so don't lynch me."
#558, #563 Lots of wifom stuff. Not sure it helps us to be made to dwell on what PPS said when he was obviously trying to hurt us.
#582 More about the zigaton softclaim that he drew attention to the first time he challenged Ash on it.
Posts in which he claims out-right to be town: #74, #202, #258, #557
Posts in which he claims out-right to be IC: #256, #312, #538
Lessons learned:
1) JR has been throwing suspicion on Ash for longer than I'd realised. Though after RVS, he was only really voting for Ash for a very short time between early D2 and the point at which LL outed PPS.
2) He really likes telling us he's town and IC. Is that even a good thing to do if you really are town? I guess it's a thing that Ash will be able to tell use from meta?
3) The thing he's mostly throwing at Ash now is the fact that he drew attention to Zigaton's soft-claim. However, re-reading that bit now makes it look like it was really JR calling unnecessary attention to Ash's casual query, so maybe it's JR who did something questionable there, especially since LL picked him up on it right afterwards.