I'm on a train, so apologies for lack of useful quoting and stuff!
I've been re-reading the game, and I still think JR is iffy. The vote-jumping happened well into D1, not just in RVS, and while the FH might have looked nice for catching scum, he revealed a PR, which is really bad for us.
I feel like we might want to keep all three of the oldie people around right now because we can't trust any given one alone. We'll gain actual PR evidence soon, and we'll benefit from having them around to help make best use of it. Ash, I'd feel better if you were to say more things to balance the other two out, or at least to let us know you endorse what they're saying rather than keeping everything to yourself :-)
I agree that either RR or Zigaton could be using quiet to hide scummy natures, but I'd rather go for JR still :-( I do get that it's more useful to vote for someone who might get lynched more easily in time, but JR is way more suspicious than RR, and I guess RR would be my next choice given the D1 pass business. Is nobody else feeling this?