All roles and alignments are assigned randomly using a random number generator.
This is true for all mafia games on f.ds.
except bastard :
)
Vote: Hydrad for being suspiciously fast.
vote: Awaclus, because I wanted to be first to vote for Hydrad
How do we know xxpittip isn't someone SS is going to control.
You don't. pit is my pet. see what I did there?
If we don't get any direct scumslips or other scummy behavior from anyone though, then I don't necessarily disagree with the idea that lynching an experienced player might be a good move. I'm not familiar enough with Mafia to say for sure if you're right or not, but at least what you're saying sounds plausible. Also, since an experienced player is less likely to make a mistake when playing as scum, in the absence of such mistakes, it makes it appear more likely that at least one experienced player is in the mafia.
I don't think that's correct, and it's definitely not how we do it most of the time. If a good player is town, he is usually a high target for scum to nightkill. if you lynch him, they don't have to do that anymore. likewise, if you don't lynch him, he might just prove his towniness by dying.
I say let's lynch who we collectively think is the scummiest. Lynching me or ADK just because there's a slight possibility that we're scum is pretty much a random lynch. Let's start basing our votes on actual scummy behavior.
Yea, agreed. Do you know that in my first real game, you were one of my biggest town reads, and you were also scum? gotta be careful.
I don't like this post. RVS stage is bad? why? you need something to base initial discussion on. I also don't see how mpspers post made him towny. I think that's easily something noob!scum could post
at least we agree on the noob!doens't!know!that!roles!are!distributed!randomly thing
in my first overall game, which was a bliz game, was got to be survivor, and I asked mali mi per pm if he assigned this role randomly, and he said yes, all roles are assigned randomly. so, it's plausible that a new town wouldn't know.
... actually hold on, a new scum wouldn't know this either. what are you saying?
vote: ADKplease don't accidentally lynch me!
Just letting people know if you are the 5th one to vote for someone and didn't realize that you were the fifth you aren't really able to go back and "unvote" it saying it was by accident. So when people are L-2 or L-1 especially be careful when throwing votes around.
anyways back to me. Looks like I have a wagon on me. Well your all wrong because I'm town. and unless your scum you don't want to kill me. So its pretty obvious that you should vote for scum instead of me.
has anyone ever told you that you're cute?
for everyone else, this kind of freaking out would be a massive scum tell. but not for you. though, if you ever play somewhere where people don't know you, you should not defend yourself that much.
I say let's lynch who we collectively think is the scummiest. Lynching me or ADK just because there's a slight possibility that we're scum is pretty much a random lynch. Let's start basing our votes on actual scummy behavior.
This is definitely to early to risk a hammer on Hydrad. Unvote
I agree with Andrew that all the talk about lynching someone who is a veteran player might be strategically reasonable is nonsense. We should just focus in finding out who is mafia and lynch him.
I'm interested in seeing what happens though, so vote: Hydrad and now it's L-2 unless I'm mistaken.
Why should we already test out what happens? Not everybody has even posted here yet. We should wait.
is this really your second game? that post doesn't look like it.
no, i already said Hydrad always pancis. why aren't you reading my posts?