Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

What happened here?  So dead.

[Galzria]

Well, you know what they say: "No news is good news!"

I mean, people around these parts could ACTUALLY be dead - so be careful what you wish for!

Votecount: 2.3
 
Eevee (2): Ashersky, Archetype
Dsell (4): Eevee, mcmcsalot, Cuzz, Shraeye {L-2}
Archetype (1): Insomniac
Cuzz (1): Yuma
Ashersky (1): Qvist

Not Voting {1}: Dsell

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline is February 4th, 10:00 PM forum time.

[mcmcsalot]

yea...dsell got to l-2 and eeeveryone shut up. So Insom/yuma/qvist talk about what your opinion of dsell and eevee are

[Insomniac]

yea...dsell got to l-2 and eeeveryone shut up. So Insom/yuma/qvist talk about what your opinion of dsell and eevee are

... I've said my opinion on them both a billion times, but here it is again

Dsell is SK or town, regardless of which I don't want to lynch him. Eevee IS town so I don't want to lynch him. I want to lynch off wagon and since I don't want to lynch myself or Dsell I want to lynch either Shraeye or Archetype, and my vote is on Arch for lurking more than anyone else.

[Eevee]

why cant dsell be mafia?

i'm dead everywhere else,should mean i can pick this game up again!

[ashersky]

Why does Insom not suspect you?  Should I add mason to your list of powers?

[yuma]

sure why not... he is just as likely to be scum as he isn't in my eyes... vote: dsell

[Dsell]

Booo guys. This entire event is the wrong thing to be looking at today. It has been an ENORMOUS distraction from all kinds of good day 2 activities.

[mcmcsalot]

Alight if noone wants to hammer dsell, I think is scum but I would be okay with lynching arch for mega lurking.

[mcmcsalot]

What are these good D2 activities? I think the issue is we have no activity hence why I'm willing to spend time lynching all lurkers moving forward from this point

[Qvist]

So, Dsell is on L-1. Can anybody summarize why? Only because Eevee found out he has a gun?

[Dsell]

We are all lurking. Nothing is happening because the Eevee/me thing has been the focal point of the day, and it is probably an argument between 2 town. Scum are more than happy to add fuel to the fire without adding any other content. There are all kinds of other things we can do on D2, no least of which is to go back and look at players' interactions with dead players.

I am still wiling to vote for Ashersky for his major day 1 weirdness with Eevee.

Vote: Ashersky

[Dsell]

Also very willing to vote cuzz for his willingness to flow with the tide of my wagon. Iirc, he unvoted when a couple people criticized my wagon, and then revoted when a couple more people expressed approval.

[Dsell]

Also very willing to vote cuzz for his willingness to flow with the tide of my wagon. Iirc, he unvoted when a couple people criticized my wagon, and then revoted when a couple more people expressed approval.

Wait, I think this was actually mcmc, sorry.

[Dsell]

ALSO willing to vote Archetype, who has been utterly silent except immediately after being called out for lurking.

[Qvist]

Ok, I didn't contribute that much. Let's change that. My top scum read is Archetype at the moment.

Gosh, I don't know who to believe.

Eevee isn't this messy as scum, but so many things that he says just don't make any sense.

Dsell's defense sounds very sincere and I think he could possibly be framed.

I think we should lynch Eevee. If he turns up town, we have 1 IC (Qvist) and 1 maybe scum (Dsell). If he turns up scum, we have 1 maybe scum (Qvist) and 1 IC (Dsell). The problem is, with the high possibly of their not being 2 Doctors, it's going to be very hard to keep ICs alive, so I don't know.

mcmc and Cuzz are kind of coming up scummy here, just jumping on the nearest wagon.

This was his post after named as lurking. He jumped in and posted that. My guess currently is that both Dsell and Eevee are town. If you read that with this in mind, it's obvious. He wants to kill one townie to show one IC that can be killed by mafia and leave one "seemingly obvious" Mafia which we lynch the next day what gives basically the win for Mafia.

I think we should lynch Eevee. If he turns up town, we have 1 IC (Qvist) and 1 maybe scum (Dsell). If he turns up scum, we have 1 maybe scum (Qvist) and 1 IC (Dsell). The problem is, with the high possibly of their not being 2 Doctors, it's going to be very hard to keep ICs alive, so I don't know.

If folks are going to believe Eevee, well your bolded sentence is out the window.  If Eevee's truthful, it's also possible there's a ninja-strongman-bulletproof-untrackable X-shot doctor in the game.

That's why I'm wondering if...

A. The lynch isn't getting off because Eevee is really Town we are the only ones who really disagree with that

B. The lynch isn't getting off because Eevee is scum and scum buddies are diverting

I really hope its the the former, and I'm just being ridiculous. But if it's the latter, it's going to be incredibly difficult to get Eevee lynched.

The last sentence really annoys me here. He really shows that he wants to lynch Eevee.

I think Eevee should fullclaim. Right now.

Why? Well there is no reason for him not to, if his powers really are that great at catching scum, he's  going to die tonight regardless if he fullclaims or not. (Barring Doctoring). So he might as well do it, correct? This is the only way he can fully convince me that his intentions are indeed good and get my vote off of him.

And then this. Here is the logic error. If his powers are great he won't die tonight. If he doesn't claim Mafia won't know if his powers are great or not. But Mafia wants to know his strange powers, so that they know if they not rather should kill him or keep with WIFOM. Also, I don't know if I reading to much in this, using the word fullclaim is scummy, why not just say "Eevee should claim"? He is really forcing the claim.

Vote: Archetype

[mcmcsalot]

vote: archetype let's get this game going

[Dsell]

Vote: Archetype

That's L-2

[shraeye]

Also very willing to vote cuzz for his willingness to flow with the tide of my wagon. Iirc, he unvoted when a couple people criticized my wagon, and then revoted when a couple more people expressed approval.

Wait, I think this was actually mcmc, sorry.

Hmmm, yes.  i remember mcmc being a blip on my radar.  But I'm ok with your lynch today.  Still, what is the case on mcmc?

[Eevee]

No hammering before I get a chance to reread the entire day 2 please, as Dsell noted I've been way too focused on him all of day 2. It's my understanding we aren't pressed on time yet, so why not try to do some rereading before we hit night (like Qvist just did, for example).

Okay if I get lazy like I did in DS9 and don't actually do it, fine just hammer away. But at least 24 hours, I think I'll really do it this time and who knows what I'll find!

[shraeye]

ALSO willing to vote Archetype, who has been utterly silent except immediately after being called out for lurking.

You bussin' here? Or is archetype town?

[Eevee]

Oh and absolutely no hammering before Insomniac gets to reply why he thinks Dsell can't be mafia. Super interested in that, if he really has something.

[Insomniac]

No hammering before I get a chance to reread the entire day 2 please, as Dsell noted I've been way too focused on him all of day 2. It's my understanding we aren't pressed on time yet, so why not try to do some rereading before we hit night (like Qvist just did, for example).

Okay if I get lazy like I did in DS9 and don't actually do it, fine just hammer away. But at least 24 hours, I think I'll really do it this time and who knows what I'll find!

Shouldn't be an issue I think Dsell is L-3 (mcmc moved). While Archetype is at L-2.

[Insomniac]

Oh and absolutely no hammering before Insomniac gets to reply why he thinks Dsell can't be mafia. Super interested in that, if he really has something.

I've already said but here it is for the third (fourth?) time. I've been scum with dsell in RMM1. Was LITERALLY the same person with him in Mafia 13 (and scum). Was town when he was mafia in MIV and I fully followed that game even after I died. Was scum against his town in RMM4. Was scum against his town in blitz something or other.

I feel I read Dsell pretty well and the entire way he's handled the case on him is not how scum Dsell handles things, so he strikes me at least in that way as town Dsell. I have never known a Dsell to lurk and here he has lurked so he COULD be sk.

If he's town vig I don't want to lynch him. If he's SK it's in his interests to shoot mafia so I don't want to lynch him.

[Dsell]

Oh and absolutely no hammering before Insomniac gets to reply why he thinks Dsell can't be mafia. Super interested in that, if he really has something.

I've already said but here it is for the third (fourth?) time. I've been scum with dsell in RMM1. Was LITERALLY the same person with him in Mafia 13 (and scum). Was town when he was mafia in MIV and I fully followed that game even after I died. Was scum against his town in RMM4. Was scum against his town in blitz something or other.

I feel I read Dsell pretty well and the entire way he's handled the case on him is not how scum Dsell handles things, so he strikes me at least in that way as town Dsell. I have never known a Dsell to lurk and here he has lurked so he COULD be sk.

If he's town vig I don't want to lynch him. If he's SK it's in his interests to shoot mafia so I don't want to lynch him.

I think Insomniac is right; there is probably no one on f.ds who reads me better than him. In fact, in the last blitz game I played, I was highly (and correctly) suspicious of him for suspecting me when I thought the case was bad. He changed his tune and I stopped suspecting him.

All that to say, Insomniac is right here but I can't help but feel that he could be buddying up to me to gain towncred in my eyes.