On that note, how important does everyone think it is to determine which kill was mafia and which kill was by the witch/woodcutter/militia? And conversely, how bad is it if we're wrong?
I don't think it's very do-able, especially seeing as the mafia currently has a much bigger proportion of town discussion than us and can easily mislead the town thoughts. However, it could be possible to discuss, although I think it'll just devolve down to 'I think X was more town than Y'.
That said, personally I think theorel was more likely the woodcutter/witch kill. There was suspicion against him, and he cast the hammer, which in some people's eyes is enough to raise suspicion level. Imsomniac has been generally relatively quiet but slightly helpful, and would be a safe mafia kill.
SFS, thanks for that. Now I'm not going to survive past night 2, most likely (unless a doctor protects me). I've been mentioning inactivity because I know I've been inactive due to RL, and generally by the time I reply someone has mentioned 'Oh look Tables is inactive still'. I'm also apparently a lot less able to keep up with proper mafia games than I thought I was.
That said, although I know his result is true (but I'd say that anyway derp), I have no reason to believe he actually did investigate me last night, and neither does anyone else. It's plausible he's mafia, wanting to make a double cover for why he isn't dying (he's used his one shot role) and why he shouldn't be lynched (he correctly pegged a townie!). It's also possible he trusts me completely and wants to make people less suspicious of me, although honestly I can't see this one happening (while I know I'm town, I certainly haven't done enough to clear myself irrevocably). However, this could be because he as a power role of his own and wants to avoid danger on himself from the mafia. In short, I'm not going to trust SFS any more for this information, and don't think it should be regarded too strongly.
So now Theorel's dead, is it worth considering his thoughts that the bandwagon was a townie driven wagon on a townie? Obviously, we can't know for certain, but we do know who voted for Axxle1, who expressed suspicion without voting and who didn't. We also know the hammer didn't come from Mafia (as an aside, it's possible the theorel kill was based on his hammer by a suspicious Witch or vigilante). Correct me if I'm wrong but the order of votes was:
Galzria (1) - 760
Joth (2) - 848
Captain Frisk (3) - 875
SFS (4) - 883
pops (5) - 895
Glooble (6) - 1042
Grujah (7) - 1050
Theorel (
- 1162
Of those, Glooble and Grujah's votes seem the weakest, and came after quite a long break. Glooble's reasoning gave no reasons for his suspicion of Axxle, just that he was suspicious and that we would get information from the lynch. Grujah might have given a reason on an earlier page, but his vote at 1050 and post at 1048 didn't give any reasoning. The closeness of these two's votes, as well as the lack of good reasoning for pushing the wagon right up to 7 isn't exactly leaving me comfortable about them. My notes regarding day 1, however, don't give me an awful lot of other reason to be suspicious of them, but still, I'd be interested to know what reasons those two can give for their votes.