Well, skip v mail-mi here has been a tough decision. And Galz never came back and explained how he felt about ADK, which is a little annoying.
I'm townreading MiX ridiculously hard right now, so I'm tempted to sheep him, but I still don't really buy his skip case. I think he's trying too hard to make the square peg fit in the round hole. In many ways this is like a cop claim situation, where townie A says "I'm a cop and I investigated townie B and he's scum" and townie B says "No, I'm town, so townie A must be lying and saying he's a cop". What do we usually do in that situation? If it's not LyLo, we just lynch townie B, and then we lynch townie A the next day if townie B flips town. Because in our experience, it's very rare for scum to put themselves out there, especially on day 1 when all they need is a mislynch.
So if there's scum amongst mail-mi and skip, it just makes sense to vote for mail-mi, because he was the one who got caught up in this vs the one who initiated this. To me, that's the heart of the matter.
Now, you can ask whether the situation is really analogous. And you can ask whether we really will lynch skip if mail-mi flips town -- I suspect there are many ways for him to wriggle out in that case. And you can ask, as many have, if this 1 v 1 thing is really a thing. But the fact is, this is where we've arrived and I just can't defend the people who are saying 'lynch skip'.
vote: mail-mi. That's L-1.