Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Do we think Eddie has a posting restriction? Or is he just being weird for the sake of being weird?

Pfft. Scumpoints. cayvie's cool for agreeing with this.

Should we all claim our houses before the first highstorm comes? I think we should have the information out there.

Also scumpoints. But not as many.

MiX is making some sense. Good for him.

18 people is way too many people and I never know how to play these Day 1s. Also HI.

Bold suggestion you are all going to hate, but I have to put it out there anyway: We No Lynch Day 1.

Why? Two reasons.

1) There's an even number of us so we're going to have to do it eventually.
2) Everybody has approximately 1 million powers so we're likely to learn a lot in the night.

So many interesting things to talk about and joth chooses a stale old no lynch discussion. Boo.

“Perhaps I should be more clear. I think people should regularly partake of Quiet Times, (hereby referred to as ‘QTs’) for the sake of gaining information that they did not have previously.”

Vote: Eddie for claiming Cult Leader.

This is pretty ridiculous. We're no longer in RVS my friend.

Nice details mail-mi!

Sounds like Eddie is claiming Wit, a mysterious fellow who also goes by Hoid and appears in all the cosmere books, not just this series.

vote: joth. No lynch seems bad for town and his reasons were strange.

joth lynch seems bad for town and EFHW's reasons are strange.

I'm personally hard no on the stealing pact and vote: jotheonah because HARD NO on ever suggesting no lynch D1.

Not the most exciting entrance ever.

Nice details mail-mi!

Sounds like Eddie is claiming Wit, a mysterious fellow who also goes by Hoid and appears in all the cosmere books, not just this series.

vote: joth. No lynch seems bad for town and his reasons were strange.

EFHW are you scum again?

Oh cayvie, you're stealing all my thunder. Well not all of it, but still.

Am I reading the setup post right in that scum has access to the same basic set of possible powers as town? If that's true, wouldn't a no-stealing pact benefit town more on the balance? Since there's more of us?

Glooble continues to be scummy.

My town pings/reads right now

Galz
Greathallscout
Didds
Eddie

These are not all that great.

[faust]

Vote: EFHW

[faust]

Also, since noone brought this up yet and it's more interesting than House-claiming:

All Dustbringers should claim.

[faust]

I've also learned that Rhand is in my timezone. Where are you from, Rhand?

[cayvie]

Also, since noone brought this up yet and it's more interesting than House-claiming:

All Dustbringers should claim.

was this a thing that you expected someone to bring up?

[cayvie]

It is? I was thinking of suggesting a no stealing pact to my housemates.

PPE thanks

Scum would have no problem breaking that pact, and town (in my mind) would be suspicious of the others in their house since there's no reason for there not to be at least 1 scum or non-town person in your house. The trust here could be scummy, rather, it's scummy enough for a D1 Vote: EFHW.

ppe 3

What about EFHW's plan here is scummy? I don't get what you mean when you say "the trust here could be scummy".

[Rhand]

I've also learned that Rhand is in my timezone. Where are you from, Rhand?

I’m a hungover Belgian.

I’ll catch up when the painkiller kicks in

[faust]

Also, since noone brought this up yet and it's more interesting than House-claiming:

All Dustbringers should claim.

was this a thing that you expected someone to bring up?

I expected some talk about the orders at least. It's weird to me that this was completely glossed over.

[cayvie]

hey GreatHallScout and Rhand: if you want to be kind, put something ctrl+f-able in your sig or profile comment so i can isolate your posts

i think that EFHW/Dylan32 exchange i quoted a bit up the page sounds like partners distancing early. or maybe Dylan just stretching for reads. i was gonna wait for his answer to my question to decide whether to vote but patience has never been my strength

vote: Dylan32

[faust]

Are you a Dustbringer, cayvie?

[cayvie]

Are you a Dustbringer, cayvie?

no

[cayvie]

Are you a Dustbringer, cayvie?

are you?

[hypercube]

I agree that it's a good idea to make any Dustbringers claim. I'm not a Dustbringer.

[faust]

Are you a Dustbringer, cayvie?

are you?

No.

[cayvie]

Are you a Dustbringer, cayvie?

are you?

No.

huh, okay. thought you legit might be.

[Glooble]

Vote: Faust

Until someone can explain what’s pro-town about pushing for our freaking vigilante to claim day one.

[Glooble]

Am I missing something? Hypercube, why do you agree?

[MiX]

Am I reading the setup post right in that scum has access to the same basic set of possible powers as town? If that's true, wouldn't a no-stealing pact benefit town more on the balance? Since there's more of us?

That is what I was thinking.

I don't understand how this makes sense. Scum overall spends more stormlight anyway because they can do both town and scum things.

I feel like mix is trolling me

Like he knows I got in him for a nightkill TMI in Ash's game

And now he's out here making TMI statements about how many powers the different factions have, and how much Mana they cost

I'm confused. What are you referring to? There's some surge powers that only scum use (ninja lmao) so clearly they'll spend more stormlight than town.

And now he's answering for other players...

Mix I feel like you're planning to get wagoned today, survive the wagon, and then not get nightkilled because you feel you've been the right amount of obvscum.

But I don't know what alignment that makes you

Yes, yes I am, that's literally my town game, get voted on D1 and then get cleared. Getting the D1 wagon's optional though.

Reread setup, answered the first question there.

I am confused at your confusion? What am I missing here? Where did MiX suggest that skum can use kill + surge + something else?

He said scum would use more stormlight because they can do town and scum things, plural. Outside of the factional kill, what other things would scum be able to do? Some of the surges certainly have powers which would be of benefit to scum, and so I don't know that it's a given that scum has additional "scum things" beyond the factional kill. If MiX knows something of these extra powers, he must be scum.

Well I mean it says in OP we can take 3 actions per night. I dunno if it is you or me that is missing something at this point. I actually agree with mix here.

Skum can take surge pool actions and whatever special power action shit like everyone else in the Knights Radiant... Town would try to only use towny actions. As you stated not all the powers are towny. Skum will use Skummy and Towny actions... therefore skum uses more than Town. Yeah?

Rare case of Swan understanding what I'm saying and me understanding what Swan's saying.

[MiX]

Also, since noone brought this up yet and it's more interesting than House-claiming:

All Dustbringers should claim.

How is this going to help town catch scum?

[Glooble]

I'm confused. What are you referring to? There's some surge powers that only scum use (ninja lmao) so clearly they'll spend more stormlight than town.

If scum has watchers and trackers and can easily see a reason for a town player to use the ninja ability.

[Glooble]

*I can easily see*

[MiX]

I'm confused. What are you referring to? There's some surge powers that only scum use (ninja lmao) so clearly they'll spend more stormlight than town.

If scum has watchers and trackers and can easily see a reason for a town player to use the ninja ability.

I don't. I'm quite confused as why you would want to hide that you're doing stuff to scum. It's also a waste of stormlight.

[WestCoastDidds]

Also, since noone brought this up yet and it's more interesting than House-claiming:

All Dustbringers should claim.

Hi faust! Happy weekend!

Why should the Dustbringers claim?  (I am not a Dustbringer, but I want to understand)

[faust]

Vote: Faust

Until someone can explain what’s pro-town about pushing for our freaking vigilante to claim day one.

What's not pro-town about it?

[Glooble]

I'm confused. What are you referring to? There's some surge powers that only scum use (ninja lmao) so clearly they'll spend more stormlight than town.

If scum has watchers and trackers and can easily see a reason for a town player to use the ninja ability.

I don't. I'm quite confused as why you would want to hide that you're doing stuff to scum. It's also a waste of stormlight.

Scum could watch the person they kill. If they survive, now scum has found the doctor. If I’m an edgebringer I could totally see myself ninja doctoring to prevent that scenario.