Alright. Catching back up now. Doesn't look like I missed a huge amount (yay)!
First - faust, I'll pull up some quotes on Cuzz in a few here. Like I said, much of it isn't alignment indicative - but then I don't think much of what anybody has said at all over the past 1000+ posts is really alignment indicative (if it were, catching scum would be easy). There's just a number of things in the way he thinks and posts that I find more townie than scummy - and moreso with him than anybody else so far.
Second - The J Reggie wagon. There are 3 possible alignments for Reggie. Town, Mafia, SK (for this purpose SK = Wolf = Survivor). There were, at peak, 8 people voting him, with 2 "threatening" votes. Those votes were: Galz (#578), e (#876), Dylan (#883), TWM (#886), Eevee (#902), Sudgy (#952 soft, #979 full vote), iguana (#991), gkrieg (#1015). Expressed intent but never did are O (#1025) and PPS (#1050). Mcmc also indicated he would be fine with a JReg lynch, but it wasn't his top choice. Also of note is that Jake and faust voted for J Reggie in post #332 & #513 respectively - before anything significant happened.
If Reggie is Town: Of those 13 players listed above (mainly the 8 on the wagon though), I find it unlikely that we have zero of the 5-7 scum in this game aboard.
If Reggie is Mafia: I feel fairly confident that we didn't push him to L-2 with all Town votes. Even if his Mafia partners were hedging (O, PPS, Mcmc type in this case) - or actively trying to derail (Jimmm, faust, Space (and by actively I simply mean pushing elsewhere)), I highly doubt we get that much town consensus on d1.
If Reggie is SK: This is same as town above (yes? I don't see why it wouldn't be).
In all - that's a long way of saying that I would expect to find at least one scum among the 8 people on the J Reggie wagon.
Unvote
I don't think my case on J Reggie was bad. Especially for d1. I think that there was definitely some points of interest in it - but the day is young, and I think our chances of hitting scum looking at his wagon are much higher than the chance that I happened to find the smallest of scum type slips out of any player on d1.
((Also, not brought up in this post in detail is the "anti-wagon", which will also likely have scum. Lastly, there's the "avoided the whole thing" subset of players - which is ALSO likely to have scum. So YMMV on where you feel like looking. I prefer on Wagon since looking at actions is "easier" than looking at non-actions.))