Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

I don't intend to hammer, but I want Joseph to know that he's been less and less towny. That being said, I seriously doubt Joseph will get lynched today so it doesn't really matter

If you hammer me, then based on how much everyone else has posted this game, this game will just turn into a game of lurkers, like so many other games on here.

Better a game of lurkers than a game of fluffy nonsense.

[Joseph2302]

I don't intend to hammer, but I want Joseph to know that he's been less and less towny. That being said, I seriously doubt Joseph will get lynched today so it doesn't really matter

If you hammer me, then based on how much everyone else has posted this game, this game will just turn into a game of lurkers, like so many other games on here.

Someone hammer him. If he was town, he wouldn't have to threaten us like this, he could legitimately defend himself instead.

I'm SK

[Joseph2302]

Jokes, I'm UB

[faust]

*sigh*

Is this serious?

[Robz888]

Unvote

And shame on you.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

If it's fine, then what's the problem?
Other people are allowed to use stupid nicknames, so why not me?

Don't be petulant.

[gkrieg13]

vote: faust

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I don't intend to hammer, but I want Joseph to know that he's been less and less towny. That being said, I seriously doubt Joseph will get lynched today so it doesn't really matter

If you hammer me, then based on how much everyone else has posted this game, this game will just turn into a game of lurkers, like so many other games on here.

Better a game of lurkers than a game of fluffy nonsense.

And I see relatively few lurkers. There is some good participation going on. Don't try to push the status of this game onto others. Its lack of usefullness is mostly attributed to you.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Jokes, I'm UB

Do we believe this? I'm not sure I do

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Jokes, I'm UB

Oh brother.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Jokes, I'm UB

Do we believe this? I'm not sure I do

Don't we have to without a counter claim from another player claiming UB or a mason pair (potentially)? Not sure if either should at this point, I am still trying to get a grasp of game theory.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Jokes, I'm UB

Do we believe this? I'm not sure I do

And I forgot how the set-up works. I stand by my point, but less so.

[Roadrunner7671]

Jokes, I'm UB

Do we believe this? I'm not sure I do

Don't we have to without a counter claim from another player claiming UB or a mason pair (potentially)? Not sure if either should at this point, I am still trying to get a grasp of game theory.

Yep.

[Awaclus]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

[Roadrunner7671]

I don't intend to hammer, but I want Joseph to know that he's been less and less towny. That being said, I seriously doubt Joseph will get lynched today so it doesn't really matter

Why do you doubt it?

Because it's early in the day and these wagons rarely get a lynch.

Also because Joseph claimed UB, but the above part is why I made my original post.
PPE

[Roadrunner7671]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

That's good critical thinking, but I doubt scum!Joseph would claim UB. Claiming any other PR seems better.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

Well I don't think I have ever been sure. It isn't possible to be sure right now, isn't that the whole point of the game?

[Robz888]

There's only one UB, claiming it would be terrible scum play. It means Joseph is telling the truth (unless he royally screwed up and gets counterclaimed).

[IDontPlayThisGame]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

I know I brought that up, but that's mainly because I forgot how this game and set-up work. I agree with RR; the UB is nearly guaranteed to be in the game whereas other PRs might not be.

@TWM- Arguably there's a point where we know something is 100% true, but I think "sure" in this case means "reasonably sure". Also, were you calling me a veteran in a post a while back? I've played two games...

PPE: 2

[Roadrunner7671]

I've played two games

But you're good!

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Also, were you calling me a veteran in a post a while back? I've played two games...

Oh, I thought you had played more as you were referencing what looked like multiple games played with Joseph. At this point everyone is more of a vet than me.

[Joseph2302]

There's only one UB, claiming it would be terrible scum play. It means Joseph is telling the truth (unless he royally screwed up and gets counterclaimed).

Possibly the most sensible post in this entire game

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Jake, now that Joseph has claimed UB, has your opinion of his "stunts" changed?

[Awaclus]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

That's good critical thinking, but I doubt scum!Joseph would claim UB. Claiming any other PR seems better.

Not necessarily. I think the most important aspect of fakeclaiming a PR is that someone will have to counterclaim. Claiming something "safe" wouldn't make that happen, and it might not help him survive without getting lynched either.

[Joseph2302]

That depends. If we're sure that Joseph is scum, we can lynch him regardless of his claim, so that the town UB doesn't have to claim.

That's good critical thinking, but I doubt scum!Joseph would claim UB. Claiming any other PR seems better.

Not necessarily. I think the most important aspect of fakeclaiming a PR is that someone will have to counterclaim. Claiming something "safe" wouldn't make that happen, and it might not help him survive without getting lynched either.

Much safer to just claim VT, or a PR and hope that not enough people have that role.