We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.
How would we make scum our leader?
The leader was chosen randomly. We have no clue if silverspawn is scum or town. However, any attempt "to make scum our leader" is ill-conceived.
Why?
What benefit do we have making potential scum the leader? I don't see any. I much prefer just lynching scum. I also think that there may be more to being the leader than just the duel mechanic, but who knows. Anyway, I think a town leader is best.
Also, if we have a "scummy" leader who happens to be town, it makes it easier for real scum to challenge and possibly win, maybe even in a way that would prevent their own lynch. I prefer someone as leader who people think is generally town to take that away as well as preventing scum from having any other additional unknown benefit from the leader