Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[2.71828.....]

I mean, vote: no lynch is voting for silverspawn.

I do like the whole gladiator idea.  Like, it is something that could become very tempting to me depending on how the game progresses and who our current leader is.

[2.71828.....]

We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.

How would we make scum our leader?

The leader was chosen randomly.  We have no clue if silverspawn is scum or town.  However, any attempt "to make scum our leader" is ill-conceived. 

[2.71828.....]

I mean, vote: no lynch is voting for silverspawn.

I do like the whole gladiator idea.  Like, it is something that could become very tempting to me depending on how the game progresses and who our current leader is.

Don't get me wrong, I have no intention of using the gladiator option right now.  Saying that it is a tempting option for me is simply admitting that I absolutely love when a game ends up having a "me vs player X" situation and I get to have fun with arguing why we should lynch that other person.


of course, those situations are usually town vs town and I just have a bad read on Seprix.....

[2.71828.....]

But Seprix isn't in this game, so no worries about misreading him this game

[Roadrunner7671]

2.7, your vote is in the proper format, so you are currently voting for silverspawn.

[2.71828.....]

2.7, your vote is in the proper format, so you are currently voting for silverspawn.

great observation

[iguanaiguana]

silver is 100% town this game. e I'm not so sure about.

[iguanaiguana]

Chairs, are you going to be able to keep up the posting requirement?

[mail-mi]

I don't know if faust being very anti-claiming is towny or scummy. Probably null, leaning very slightly on scummy.

We should treat this day like a normal D1 and not lynch off of meta "would they choose scum?" reasons.

idk about leader.

[iguanaiguana]

I don't know if faust being very anti-claiming is towny or scummy. Probably null, leaning very slightly on scummy.

We should treat this day like a normal D1 and not lynch off of meta "would they choose scum?" reasons.

idk about leader.

Why?

[mail-mi]

I don't know if faust being very anti-claiming is towny or scummy. Probably null, leaning very slightly on scummy.

We should treat this day like a normal D1 and not lynch off of meta "would they choose scum?" reasons.

idk about leader.

Why?

Could be that he chose scum, and doesn't want to potentially be caught in a lie. Like i said, very slightly scummy.

[iguanaiguana]

I meant why do a normal D1?

[gkrieg13]

silver is 100% town this game. e I'm not so sure about.

Why is silver town?

[Witherweaver]

silver is 100% town this game. e I'm not so sure about.

Cool

Vote: Iguana

[mail-mi]

I meant why do a normal D1?

because reasons.

[iguanaiguana]

Normal D2 and on makes sense to me. Lynching based on the choice mechanic makes a lot of sense to me D1 because D1 is an awful crapshoot and this gives us better odds.

silver is town because he has rolled scum a lot recently, including in both championship games, and has stated in many places in an obviously nonlying way that he is sick of playing scum, and crosses his fingers to roll town every time. And he stated that without any foreknowledge of the fact that he would have a choice of town or scum in a later game.

silver is the one I am most sure of, who I am just not even going to consider lynching until LyLo or some serious shenanigans occur. Everyone else I am a lot less sure of.

[2.71828.....]

Cool

Vote: Iguana

[iguanaiguana]

Let's do it!

Vote: Iguana

Wagons!

Once I'm dead in here, I'll have time to work on forum survivor four.

[Roadrunner7671]

...

[Witherweaver]

Cool

Vote: Iguana

Copycat

[Witherweaver]

Normal D2 and on makes sense to me. Lynching based on the choice mechanic makes a lot of sense to me D1 because D1 is an awful crapshoot and this gives us better odds.

silver is town because he has rolled scum a lot recently, including in both championship games, and has stated in many places in an obviously nonlying way that he is sick of playing scum, and crosses his fingers to roll town every time. And he stated that without any foreknowledge of the fact that he would have a choice of town or scum in a later game.

silver is the one I am most sure of, who I am just not even going to consider lynching until LyLo or some serious shenanigans occur. Everyone else I am a lot less sure of.

Why do you so strongly believe everyone got what they chose?

[faust]

We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.

How would we make scum our leader?

I suggest you reread the setup post.

[faust]

We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.

How would we make scum our leader?

The leader was chosen randomly.  We have no clue if silverspawn is scum or town.  However, any attempt "to make scum our leader" is ill-conceived.

Why?

[faust]

Normal D2 and on makes sense to me. Lynching based on the choice mechanic makes a lot of sense to me D1 because D1 is an awful crapshoot and this gives us better odds.

silver is town because he has rolled scum a lot recently, including in both championship games, and has stated in many places in an obviously nonlying way that he is sick of playing scum, and crosses his fingers to roll town every time. And he stated that without any foreknowledge of the fact that he would have a choice of town or scum in a later game.

silver is the one I am most sure of, who I am just not even going to consider lynching until LyLo or some serious shenanigans occur. Everyone else I am a lot less sure of.

But of course silver would realize all this and thus could think that it increases his chances of winning this game if he chooses scum. It's all less clear-cut than you make it seem.

[silverspawn]

Normal D2 and on makes sense to me. Lynching based on the choice mechanic makes a lot of sense to me D1 because D1 is an awful crapshoot and this gives us better odds.

silver is town because he has rolled scum a lot recently, including in both championship games, and has stated in many places in an obviously nonlying way that he is sick of playing scum, and crosses his fingers to roll town every time. And he stated that without any foreknowledge of the fact that he would have a choice of town or scum in a later game.

silver is the one I am most sure of, who I am just not even going to consider lynching until LyLo or some serious shenanigans occur. Everyone else I am a lot less sure of.

But of course silver would realize all this and thus could think that it increases his chances of winning this game if he chooses scum. It's all less clear-cut than you make it seem.

Except I wouldn't. I immediately chose town and even if I had thought about it would have chosen town anyway.