Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

What we could talk about regarding spice, for instance, is the following:

We should instalynch any player that does not post within a timeframe of 40 hours.

[2.71828.....]

What we could talk about regarding spice, for instance, is the following:

We should instalynch any player that does not post within a timeframe of 40 hours.

Instalynch seems harsh at first, but I agree. Games with paying requirements have been seriously hampered in the past by inactive players. We don't want that.

[Roadrunner7671]

What's wrong with lynching on meta based WIFOM?

[mail-mi]

I agree with Faust. I don't think claiming will profit us much.

[faust]

I agree with Faust. I don't think claiming will profit us much.

And yet you claimed.

[mail-mi]

I agree with Faust. I don't think claiming will profit us much.

And yet you claimed.

I also don't think it will hurt.

[silverspawn]

This is interesting...but I'm not sure how we benefit from claiming. The more important matter to discuss is spice.

Well, we roughly know which persons prefer town over scum and which don't. Knowing who claimed and who didn't means we know who's more likely scum now and who isn't. Forcing scum to claim pushes them into a corner.

Which corner would that be, exactly? We can just lynch people we think are likely to have picked scum (for all the WIFOMy goodness that comes with this) if that's your pitch, but then there are no claims needed for that.

There are, because they might not have had a choice, and then we rely on false information.

Why are you resisting us claiming something that should have literally zero benefit for scum?

[Roadrunner7671]

How is this setup balanced if the majority of people picked scum?

[iguanaiguana]

Knowing that everyone had a choice is totally relevant information. Don't let Faust boss you around (General you)

[iguanaiguana]

How is this setup balanced if the majority of people picked scum?

They didn't. Or it would be game end.

[faust]

Why are you resisting us claiming something that should have literally zero benefit for scum?

I don't know how much benefit it will have for scum. I do know that it has zero benefit for town. On the offchance that it does hold some benefit for scum, I prefer to not do the claiming.

Although it arguably matters less now that chairs and me are the only ones that haven't claimed yet.

[faust]

How is this setup balanced if the majority of people picked scum?

There could be like 2 scum teams or something.

[faust]

Knowing that everyone had a choice is totally relevant information. Don't let Faust boss you around (General you)

So tell me: Who is scum?

[silverspawn]

Why are you resisting us claiming something that should have literally zero benefit for scum?

I don't know how much benefit it will have for scum. I do know that it has zero benefit for town. On the offchance that it does hold some benefit for scum, I prefer to not do the claiming.

Although it arguably matters less now that chairs and me are the only ones that haven't claimed yet.

Come on. Of course it has benefits for town. 

[mail-mi]

How is this setup balanced if the majority of people picked scum?

I have an idea about this which I'm not going to claim yet.

[iguanaiguana]

Knowing that everyone had a choice is totally relevant information. Don't let Faust boss you around (General you)

So tell me: Who is scum?

I dunno. If everyone got what they wanted, then probably me, you, silver and roadrunner are town. That's not a bad start.

[faust]

Knowing that everyone had a choice is totally relevant information. Don't let Faust boss you around (General you)

So tell me: Who is scum?

I dunno. If everyone got what they wanted, then probably me, you, silver and roadrunner are town. That's not a bad start.

Just how probable do you think it is that you are town?

[iguanaiguana]

I have never won a game as scum. I hate doing it and it makes me sweat a lot. I knee jerk picked good within a minute of reading the post then felt weirdly ashamed and cowardly for doing so. So, probable.

[Roadrunner7671]

Knowing that everyone had a choice is totally relevant information. Don't let Faust boss you around (General you)

So tell me: Who is scum?

I dunno. If everyone got what they wanted, then probably me, you, silver and roadrunner are town. That's not a bad start.

Roadrunner?

[iguanaiguana]

You've never won as scum, but like three times ore frequently than me. I thought about the choice from your perspective and figured you pick town.

[faust]

So have we successfully killed this game?

I think iguana is town probably. WW is kinda scummy.

Vote: WW

[Roadrunner7671]

So have we successfully killed this game?

I think iguana is town probably. WW is kinda scummy.

Vote: WW

I agree with Iguanaiguana, but how can you have a scum read already?

[faust]

If I can have a townread, why shouldn't I have a scumread?

[faust]

We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.

[gkrieg13]

We can think a bit about the leader mechanic. Because that confuses me. The leader cannot be lynched; however, it is pretty eas to change the leader, and the leader dies if we don't agree. Also the leader is like a universal Gladiator target. Does this role seem negative utility to anyone? Do you think we want to make scum our leader? But that sounds wrong.

How would we make scum our leader?