Just read all of Teproc. I think he's really towny overall. No idea where the people voting him are coming from.
Three things I set aside as I passed them:
1)
PPE : Boo, silver. Boo.
?
Explaining metas. Not only would it have been entertaining, it could have been revealing. Possibly annoying too, but ohwell.
PPE : Well, I only scumread you when you're scum is the thing, but I see.
That's demonstrably false.
I actually don't think it is. I'm very good at catching you. Maybe I was wrong once, but I can think of three separate times where my "ADK isn't obvtown to me, must be scum" method worked.
This is the one outright scummy thing Teproc has done that I've seen. This kind of "Oh I have this method, it works so well, at least well enough to be worth going with" is like hedging, but one step sideways: it lets you say later, "Oh no, my method! Disaster!" Rather than actually being accountable.
2)
So opinion poll:
J Reggie, gkrieg, Teproc:
Mafia, town, neither
Discuss.
Was it J Reggie trying to encourage conversation... was J Reggie going to present his reads on gkrieg/Teproc? I read it as he's having problems trying to sort those two slots. Null on the 'hey-guys-how-are-you-reading-me-right-now?' - it shows he is comfortable, but I wouldn't call it town confidence right now: I need to hear him be more expressive with his reads.
This post jumped out to me as well. J Reggie is a new player, so I don't know any more than you here, but I have the opposite read on it : I think it shows that he's nervous on what people think of him, which I think is generally a scummy trait.
Jumping on Silver? I missed that.
When silver and ADK were voting for me he criticized that and threw suspicion on both, though he focused more on ADK.
This is super townie and I agree entirely, by the way. Reggie is still a bit scummy. Read Fruit Ninja.
3)
The big thing is his pushing liopoil. He actually posts that he finds lio mildly towny, quite early on, then suddenly throws this out
I haven't had trouble getting into this game, I just have no idea what to say. I don't have a scum read and RVS is over so I shouldn't clutter the thread, so I don't know what to say.
It's lame, I know. 
Ask questions. Try to get someone to slip up.
Good idea.
Liopoil: Are you scum?
lol I didn't sign up for thks kind of interrogation. You'll make whatever I say sound scummy. Not convinced of the value of all these questions people are asking anyway.
Obviously I'm not scum though, but you already knew that right?
This is going to look ridiculous but...
vote: liopoil
Seriously, it's a simple, jokey question, but it's enough to make liopoil react defensively AND feel the need to add another post because he's scared of the way his first response is read ?
The second post is really what makes it scummy for me, town probably doesn't even take the time to respond to that in the first place, but liopoil cared enough to post twice about it !
Roadrunner best scumhunter 2016.
This is super towny. Scum really don't like to go for such a big flip-flop,
the more so when the original read was a weak one. If they've been reading someone as really strongly town, scum can get away with a drastic flip on the back of "Oh my god, why does everyone find this person scummy, what the hell, all my assumptions must be rethought!" But scum like to avoid going from mild town to strong scum, because they think it looks hedgy.
Plus his case on lio is pretty good and he's been driving that hard. If lio is town, scum would not want to be pushing that hard for a mislynch. If lio is scum, well, why bus this early? Seems crazy.
Author
Topic: M79: Sherlock Mafia (Game over!) (Read 267710 times)