@Haddock - when you have time add the supporting reasons to your early reads:
"J Reggie looks bad in places, and I think is worthy of a vote"
Haddock - as far as I can tell, you make a long post and then vote me just because I "look bad". People have been saying I'm scummy. This sort of feels like jumping on a trend without adding anything to it.
OK, so list of posts Reggie has made so far that I didn't like, with reasons where possible.
16 is a lit.
Vote: Jan
So you're not opening with "hi everybody"? That must mean you're town!
Hi everybody!
Scumslip, Vote: J Reggie
Haha, I was hoping someone would notice that.
I mean, jokes and everything, sure, but the town narrative for this has never been explained. Trying to throw off suspicion about something you said by saying "ha, glad someone noticed the funny joke I made" is scummy.
IG and Awaclus scum team. There, solved.
Proposing scumteams early on is always scummy as far as I'm concerned. It is an attempt to tie together players in people's minds and distort reads.
I'm liking this whole Seprix/melisandre thing; finding both of them townie.
I never trust a read saying "Oh this clash between these players looks like a townclash to me." Often that's a thing that town says, but it's also a very nice way for scum to look reasonable and helpful and well-reading. Without actually REALLY committing to a fullout townread on either player.
Have you been stalking me?
Haha, no, I think you and Awaclus have the easiest-to-describe metas. I do think you're one of the cooler people on f.ds though.
Buddying.
So my thought process is as follows: I thought ADK looked scummy, then realized I didn't know why I thought that, then Seprix made a case and I agreed with it. And I definitely don't have a hard scum-read on anyone, so I'm going with what I've got and seeing how people react, which is how I play the game.
The opinion poll was partially because I was having trouble forming an opinion on the two others, partially because I thought people weren't talking about them enough for how much they had continued, and also because I'm always surprised by how people read my posts. Apparently people are finding me scummy this game. That's interesting; I guess it's fine. I'm still getting used to all these new people.
I'm currently feeling pretty town on melisandre, but I'm wary of that because we might just be used to different metas.
Well, I know I don't like this post. I can't put my finger on why.
Also, if anyone has a preference for what pronouns you would like to be referred to by, let me know. I go by he/him/his. I feel like this is a thing we should do when we /in, but that probably won't catch on.
He, etc. Sorry not to reply to this earlier.
I guess this is a town-slip, maybe not. I feel like if you were mafia you would have been more aware of the flavor, and this doesn't seem like a thing you did on purpose. Although there's the whole debate over whether town-slips are real or not, but whatever.
This is like the hedgiest post in the universe. I'm not giving scum points for it, I hedge all the time on D1. But there it is.
vote: Jan
Maybe it's a scum read. Maybe it's omgus. Maybe it's Maybeline. Idk but this feels like the right vote.
If it's a gut read just say it's a gut read. I dunno, man. This jokeish thing is kinda ugly.
OK so it's all a stretch. But my D1 stuff always is, and especially so this game.
I'm sure I could find someone I'd rather vote for. But I'm so tired. Man 16 player mafia is TOUGH. I'll get to it.
PPE - gkrieg. OK, I wasn't sure if you meant liked the post, or "like the idea of voting Haddock or Teproc based on the last page".
Author
Topic: M79: Sherlock Mafia (Game over!) (Read 267705 times)