Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Vote Count 3.2
A village explainer. Excellent if you were a village, but if you were not, not. ― Gertrude Stein on Ezra Pound

Seprix (2): Witherweaver, XerxesPraelor
Witherweaver (2): QuickSync, Seprix
Ghacob (1): chairs
silverspawn (1): Ghacob
Not Voting (3): silverspawn, Axxle, faust

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch, 5 to no-lynch.
Day 3 ends Friday September 11 at 2 PM forum time..

[faust]

I'm guessing the more likely scenario is that Seprix is Sudgy's partner and just misplayed once Sudgy was outed.  Botched claims happen.  (E.g., TA in Mistborn.)

Jesus Christ, I'm not stupid! vote: WW

But you are. You misplayed. Well, unless you're a mime. Are you?

[faust]

Sorry, that came out wrong. I didn't mean to say you are stupid. Only, if you are town, clearly you should see that you misplayed. So it's not too far-fetched for WW to assume you might also misplay as scum.

[faust]

So, riddle me this:

We go into night with two claimed PRs, among them the most dangerous PR of all (the Watcher). The single best play for mafia is to kill the Watcher. It can only be blocked by the Mimes, who have no interest in blocking the kill.

Yet the mafia does not kill the Watcher. Neither do they kill the other claimed PR (which, by the way, would also have been a pretty stupid move). Instead, they kill some random other guy.

This pretty much proves to me that the single mafia player left didn't really think their decision through. Which narrows down the lynch pool significantly, I think.

This answers my Question. However, what about the lack of Vigs?

Well... it's weird. I don't really know, but I guess vig is a difficult role to play here. I thought about vig claiming a bit, but mainly, if the vig claims, it's super bad, because we effectively lose our vig shot forever. So two possibilities:

A) Vig found scum and is quietly trying to push that without claiming
B) Vig messed up and didn't shoot/somehow managed to hit scum's NK targets.

[faust]

vote: seprix

How can you be voting for Seprix without having heard a counterclaim?

[faust]

I think I want to lynch among chairs/Ghacob/Xerxes.

This pretty much proves to me that the single mafia player left didn't really think their decision through. Which narrows down the lynch pool significantly, I think.

I don't know whether to be insulted - I'm pretty sure I'd know to kill the watcher since there's no doctor.

Well... I don't really think it's possible, but with the other players, I think it's even less possible. Basically someone's gotta be behind this.

[faust]

Well, but how about vote: Ghacob?

[Axxle]

vote: ww

at this point either seprix or ww is lying. If seprix is lying he's either mafia or mime. If he was mine he would have selflynched.... Probably. Not sure if he realized he could. If he's mafia his play was pretty suicidal. So I think he's tellling the truth.
That means ww is lying. He's either a mime or mafia. His interactions with sudgy are pretty bad and he doesn't seem mimish.

I don't get where this ghacob thing came from.

[Axxle]

vote: ghacob
After actually thinking about it for more than a second

[QuickSync]

vote: ww

at this point either seprix or ww is lying. If seprix is lying he's either mafia or mime. If he was mine he would have selflynched.... Probably. Not sure if he realized he could. If he's mafia his play was pretty suicidal. So I think he's tellling the truth.
That means ww is lying. He's either a mime or mafia. His interactions with sudgy are pretty bad and he doesn't seem mimish.

I don't get where this ghacob thing came from.

He would have to be Mime then, and I'm just not seeing that. Seprix said WW was a PR and WW said he's not so if WW is lying he would have to be either Mime or PT.

[Axxle]

You're misreading what neopolitan does.

[QuickSync]

You're misreading what neopolitan does.

K, tell me then.

[Seprix]

vote: ghacob
After actually thinking about it for more than a second

Explain?

[QuickSync]

You're misreading what neopolitan does.

K, tell me then.

You're misreading what neopolitan does.

This is good. It seemed that Seprix made it out to look like he gets the result PR or non-PR. I guess its pretty worthless at this point.

[Seprix]

vote: ww

at this point either seprix or ww is lying. If seprix is lying he's either mafia or mime. If he was mine he would have selflynched.... Probably. Not sure if he realized he could. If he's mafia his play was pretty suicidal. So I think he's tellling the truth.
That means ww is lying. He's either a mime or mafia. His interactions with sudgy are pretty bad and he doesn't seem mimish.

I don't get where this ghacob thing came from.

He would have to be Mime then, and I'm just not seeing that. Seprix said WW was a PR and WW said he's not so if WW is lying he would have to be either Mime or PT.

All I know is that WW ain't VT.

[Axxle]

vote: ghacob
After actually thinking about it for more than a second

Explain?

maybe later

[QuickSync]

I have a town read on Axxel fwiw.

[Witherweaver]

Do you have a lynch Seprix read?  Because you should.

[QuickSync]

Do you have a lynch Seprix read?  Because you should.

I'm on the fence about it.

[Seprix]

Do you have a lynch Seprix read?  Because you should.

If I get lynched, you'll be found a liar, and there's no way you'll get away with it. You know this! You're totally a goon.

[XerxesPraelor]

Do you have a lynch Seprix read?  Because you should.

If I get lynched, you'll be found a liar, and there's no way you'll get away with it. You know this! You're totally a goon.

That's evidence he isn't a goon.

[XerxesPraelor]

unvote because now I'm thinking Seprix might be mime. I'll reread ghqcob.

[Seprix]

Do you have a lynch Seprix read?  Because you should.

If I get lynched, you'll be found a liar, and there's no way you'll get away with it. You know this! You're totally a goon.

That's evidence he isn't a goon.

I keep saying Goon, and I mean Mime.

[faust]

That's too many votes on Ghacob for me to feel comfortable.

unvote

I don't want this Day ended without silver having a chance to post.

[QuickSync]

IO have a town read on Faust. He's posting way too much to be scum IMO.