Why shouldn't we lynch Hugo?
Because!
Okay, let's see, you wanted my response to your case.
Reread of Hugo. I'll cover every post since there's only like 15.
#129 Hedges on the song claiming. Votes sudgy (I think this is a good vote).
#227 Answers sudgy's question about his mafia experience. Says he doesn't suspect Hydrad and is confused as to why others do. Also notes this Fun fact: WW and ADK voted twice right after each other on the same person.
#242 More on that point.
#272 Votes ADK for voting sudgy. Basically accuses ADK of being a hypocrite since ADK was originally against the sudgy wagon and found Hugo suspicious for jumping it. ADK points out this was very early in the game.
#338 Announces that he is sick and will post his thoughts later.
Well, so far so good. Also, I feel like you wanted to mention my ADK/WW-thing, but didn't want to go to deep into it. A bit confirmation BIASed if you ask me.
#395 A very strange post. Apologizes for lurking and says he doesn't have much to say. scumtell much?
Says he finds me "very suspicious" based on an earlier post made by Teproc? citing my play in (Stack the Deck) which he had confused with Zelda. So basically sheeping a read based on a prior game he hasn't even looked at. Finishes with saying he still likes his vote where it is though, despite me being "very suspicious".
This is quoting out of context. What I literally said was: "I must say I do find the way some people base their arguments of other people there style. I know this can be useful, but still, it's really confusing for me to read: Ichi is very suspicious, because he played like this in Zelda mafia, or whatever. I haven't read all games, nor do I plan to do so."
So, while mentioning your name and Teprocs argument, I try to say I can't make up my mind about these arguments, because I don't have any experience with your playstyle.
#533 Another odd post. Basically saying that he feels no need to be townie by posting "little posts" which he believes the only purpose of which is to make people think you're town. It seems he forgot he posted in the interim after he had said he was sick. He states that he was the one that derphammered in Fish Mafia. Says he still thinks ADK is scum but the quickness of his wagon makes him wary. He believes that neither XP or I are voting ADK (although I am voting ADK at this point). Says that my vote on sudgy makes me look bad for some unknown (read: nonexistent) reason and then votes me to "see what happens".
Well, honestly, I didn't remember that post. Don't know what I was thinking. Probably a bit the same as with the vote on Sudgy, I really wasn't reading properly. "See what happens" was purely because I was very interested in what would happen, hoping it would give more insight. Well, it does.
#538 Responding to xxpittip's short case on ADK. Takes issue with the fact that xxpittip voted him previously. He disagree's with xxpittip's assessment that ADK's flip will give town a lot of information. Makes an interesting point about not voting active players. Concludes by saying he thinks the reasons xxpittip gives for voting ADK are bad.
No comments needed
#539 Correcting his prior statement that ADK was a PR, possible scumslip (But I don't really believe in those anyways).
Er... No. I was giving an example and here I'm repeating again it was an example.
#542 Responding to Eevee's vote on him and questioning why Hugo voted me. His response obviously gives no information or supporting statements.
#545 Disagrees with WW that his post indicated that he thought ADK was scum.
#547 Quotes a small portion of his #533 and tries to use it as evidence showing he didn't really think ADK was scum?
No, again. What I'm trying to prove to WW is the fact I don't say I think ADK is surely scum. I think he very well might be, but I explain why I don't vote for him. WW accused me of making a case, and I quote myself to prove I didn't.
#551 Better response to people questioning why he voted me. He cites these reasons: I've voted for Ichi because:
-As I recall, he was lurking in the beginning (not very strong)
-He voted Sudgy before, who's flipped town. Also, he had a bit of a strange role in that vote.
-He hasn't voted ADK before, but seems to be jumping on the wagon anyway to quicklynch a town player
That last one contradicts ADK being scum, but yeah, I think it's very possible for Ichi to be scum.
I'll let you make of them what you will, obviously I'm biased, but I think they're terrible.
Well, I unvoted, didn't I? Okay, later, but yeah.
#586 Ooh. My favorite. Accuses me of starting "drama". I won't address the rest of the first and second paragraphs. Backtracks his vote on me because obviously there was nothing against me to begin with. Puts a good vote on XP for being opportunistic (this is also OMGUS).
I don't accuse you of starting drama. What I meant was that it was a bit dramatic to say I 'disappeared' after I was gone for about an hour or so. No comments on the emotions, those things happen.
I like the fact this is the third time you liked something I've done but you still are sure I'm scum.
Also, is OMGUS not every vote that is based JUST on the fact someone voted for you? Otherwise, yeah, most votes from me will be OMGUS, I have the most votes, so that's just some plain statistics.
#588 A small addition to his vote on XP questioning why he voted him.
I'm too tired to provide a big final conclusion or interpretation right now. Short story: I think Hugo is newbie scum.
Well, I'll conclude this:
You've reread me with a Hugo-is-scum-feeling and have therefore (I assume by accident) misunderstood some things of what I've said/not read carefully. I think, the only argument that still stands is my bad reread in post #533. That's a decent argument. I think there are more compelling cases though, but if you disagree, please response to this, so I can see where the confusion lies.
Author
Topic: M54: Musical Mafia - GAME OVER: MAFIA WIN! (Read 122364 times)