So, let's see what Pit has said, as he hasn't posted much (although, still more than me (shame, shame)).
So, his first post is about the song claiming, saying 'song claiming wouldn't help anyone' as there's no way to verify whether everybody speaks the truth. This is a good point, but this doesn't read town nor scum.
Then, he votes for XP, saying that he hasn't said anything since the start of the game.
Then, after loads of discussion, he shows up again and says that this is his second game and unvotes, because XP has said something. A bit weird is the fact that he apparently has no opinion on the whole Sudgy-wagon discussion. That's more scummy than town to me.
Post about having no time.
Then, a reaction to make the rhyming of chairs a little more comprehensible. Still nothing extremely towny or scummy to me.
He then joins the ADK-wagon, and this is interesting, as ADK already has some votes. Pit doesn't cite really new reasons, both reasons he gives have been used before. So, a little bit sheeping on a wagon that already is pretty big. That's kind of scummy.
He than continues to attack ADK, saying he hasn't defended himself yet. This is a bit more town to me, because it makes his vote feel less sheepish to me. He seems to really believe in the wagon.
Again more pressure on ADK, citing all people who voted for him. Funnily enough, he forgets my vote? But overall, this isn't a very interesting post.
He thén points out Silver has been a bit quiet for some time. That's pretty towny to me, or at least not very sheep-scumlike.
And then, the scummiest moment for now, he derpshammers Sudgy. He hasn't said anything about Sudgy being scummy so far, so where did that vote come from? It really seems like someone trying to end the day, a.s.a.p., even if he had miscounted the votes. Putting someone on L-1 without citing any reasons is very sheepscum-stuff.
Next day: He starts again voting ADK. Then, why the Sudgy vote the day before? That starts to make less and less sense to me.
Then, he switches. While ADK was superscum at the beginning of the day and there has been not much movement on that front, he decides to vote for a lurker now (namely, me).
THEN, he goes back to vote ADK. Citing this:
The problem with lynching one of them is that we don't get any information when they flip town / scum, since we can't analyse posts that don't exist.
(..)
1. I still think of him as the scummiest player.
2. If he gets lynched we get tons of information from all the posts by him (since he is one of the most active players) and all the posts mentioning him and the two wagons he had on him so far.
3. I don't want to wait for an answer from Hugo, since he didn't post anything for almost 7 days now.
Besides the sudden shift, again, which I think is plausible for a town player, the second reason is very strange. I've pointed this out before, but this is a ridiculously weak reason to vote for someone. Also, if point 1 is true, then why did he vote for me before? Just to poke a lurker? If that's true, than point 3 is again weird. I get a really scummy vibe from this post.
Unvote. The last few days ADK didn't feel as scummy to me as before (that doesn't mean that i think he is town - he is just less scummy) and i think the hugo wagon is justified. I'm not completely sure if i want to vote for him just now, but if he doesn't show up soon and convince me he is town i will propably vote for him.
Mmm.. So, back again? This is some weird voting behavior..
Thén, funnily enough he names all people in order of scummyness, saying that ADK is his top scum and me his second. So, why not vote ADK?
Also, after that he votes for XP (who has the most votes by now) who was 4th on that list of people.
Then, this day, he claims VT after being on L-1. I think VT is an easy claim for newbie scum, as it doesn't really need extra information to support the claim.
Let's
vote: xxpittip here. I'm pretty convinced this is the right call.
About Ichi, I can see the case. I really don't like the early claim and his post about me is a very strange one (also, because he was swayed pretty easily, maybe he didn't want to make a fuss about it?). So, yeah, I think he might very well be scum. But I think the pit case is a little more compelling right now, so I'll stick there.