I'm with ash on this one. vote: reinoe. He could be trying to frame him, but I don't like the subtle defenses people have given reinoe (Teproc and ADK iirc). I am a firm, firm believer that scum defends their partners obviously, and I have like no trust of Teproc at the moment.
This is you clearly making the argument that people subtly defending reinoe makes him scummier, is it not ?
I read it as him casting suspicion on the defenders, not making reinoe scummier.
The "but" makes it counterpoint to the proceeding clause. Ichi said "Maybe Reinoe is town (i.e., framed by scum!Ash), but here is some evidence against that thought".
If you want to parse it, I think the wording suggests that the "he" from right after the vote refers to "ashersky." I think it would read:
"I'm with ash on this one. vote: reinoe. ash could be trying to frame reinoe, but I don't like the subtle defense non-ash-players have given reinoe (Teproc and ADK, for example). I am a firm, firm believer that scum defends their partners, obviously, and I have like no trust of Teproc at the moment."
I think he missed the comma after partners in the last line and that he meant "I obviously am a firm believe that scum defends their partners" and NOT that the defense is done in an obvious manner.