thoughts:
2 mafia out of 7. Looking at the wagons:
Robz (PR):
ash (scum-lynched day 2), Galz,
Volt (VT killed Night1), joth, grujah,
Frisk (PR killed night2), eevee (PR-killed night3)Ashersky (scum): gruj,
frisk(PR-night2), eevee(PR night3), shray, Insom, joth
Archetype (VT): cuzz, shray, galz, joth, insom
Looking at the list of players, I'd say that Grujah is my biggest townread. He got heavy suspicion for being on Robz wagon near the end, but we already saw that Frisk/Eevee were also in late positions on that wagon. Ashersky was the first on Robz, and obviously never unvoted once he heard Robz claim PR. I suspect that if there are more scum on this wagon, they are more likely to be Galz and joth than Grujah.
Yuma is the only player to have avoided both town wagons so far, but he also wasn't on the ashersky wagon. Also, we cut him off yesterday before he could do some analysis he was planning on doing.
My biggest scumread is Galzria. He was on both townie wagons, off of the ashersky wagon, and is in a position early on Robz's wagon. He was super weird around the claims of ash/eevee/frisk as well.
On an individual level, I still find Eevee the scummiest. However I also find his claim to be slightly more believable than Ashersky.
Ashersky also has the fact that he was chickened at a time when it looked like we were going to trust all chickens (at the very least not lynch them).
Of the three, I think Ashersky has the highest chance of being a lie, but I'm willing to lynch Eevee off base scumminess as well. CF I think will have to wait until another day, or hopefully he'll be able to prove his claim.
Haven't caught up yet, but starting to read. My biggest scum read yesterday was Eevee, which I was obviously wrong on. Following him were Arch and Ash. Ash went down as scum, and others have drawn connections to Arch over it. I need to reread him still, but that would be my preferred direction today based on what I've seen and feel from days past.
The thing about Eevee... Is he was willing to actually claim his role right after claiming PR - no thought of a counter-claim... Or at least, no worry of one. Which makes me think his PR claim is true(r).
He is constantly flipping around ashersky and eevee. He says that eevee's claim rings truest of the three, but that eevee is his #1 scum read while ashersky was his #3 read. And his vote ends up on Archetype on day 2. Seriously, go back and read some of the comments that he put down near the end of day 2.
[BY FRISK]
This actually really interesting. Forcing claims today will prevent mislynch tomorrow, but will guarantee that the cutpurse dies tonight.
if asher is town - then we absolutely want the claims. If asher is scum, we don't. Because i believe asher is scum, I'm willing to chance it.
This is exactly what I'm teetering on. Town Ash = claiming good. Scum Ash = claiming bad.
Why teeter, if you think ashersky is your 3rd biggest scumread? And when ashersky is at L-1 and Insomniac gives intent to hammer
3.5 hours to go, right? We should wait for Ashersky to respond if possible... Although outside of actually forcing claims, I don't know what would change.
Another interesting aspect of Galzria that pops out as I scroll through his posts, is that he is very often talking to or responding to Insomniac. This along with Insom's bus-type position on ashersky make me slightly suspicious of insom as well.
Vote: Galzria