Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

If the remaining scum chose to No Kill on N7, would you allow a D8?  Or will you call the game since that's ridiculous?

[yuma]

If the remaining scum chose to No Kill on N7, would you allow a D8?  Or will you call the game since that's ridiculous?

I'll let you know if it gets to that point

[ashersky]

If the remaining scum chose to No Kill on N7, would you allow a D8?  Or will you call the game since that's ridiculous?

I'll let you know if it gets to that point

raerae, the honorable way to win would be to allow for another day where Jimmmmm could actually vote.  Clearly, as scum, it makes more sense for you to just kill if this deadlines out, though.

If you do, please kill me.

[ashersky]

Can we get a prod on Jimmmmm?

Did this happen?  I was thinking maybe an email ding might wake him up or something.

[yuma]

Can we get a prod on Jimmmmm?

Did this happen?  I was thinking maybe an email ding might wake him up or something.

He was prodded after the request was submitted.

[ashersky]

Looks like game over.

Congrats scum.

[yuma]

Thread Locked

[yuma]

Mafia Wins!

ashersky and Jimmmm have been endgamed.

Congrats to raerae (The Cook), liopoil (Yvette the Maid) and nkirbit (Wadsworth the Butler)!

Speccy QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/HSrnhwmTCtU
Mafia QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/GkFWVAF8PPiC6

This Tread is Now Open Forever

[nkirbit]

That's not a fun way to end.  I wonder who Jimm would have chosen.

[Voltaire]

So, ash...honest question, asked in good faith...how did you think your playstyle this game would help town?

[Robz888]

I will defend ash here. I don't think he played nearly as crazily as other people claim, and he made himself obviously town, which is a major benefit in the endgame! That Jim squandered unfortunately.

[Voltgloss]

I was only watching the end, but man, what a heartbreaker.  My condolences ash.  Congrats, scum.

[Voltaire]

I will defend ash here. I don't think he played nearly as crazily as other people claim, and he made himself obviously town, which is a major benefit in the endgame! That Jim squandered unfortunately.

He lynched a PR with no chance to claim D1, he staunchly opposed a "broken" pro-town plan, he got into a huge town-v-town fight with the only remaining PR later, and he certainly didn't make himself obvious (in my opinion), and as far as I can tell, in the opinion of most (in-thread and in the spectator thread). Which is why I'm curious for ash's take.

[liopoil]

well, we won I guess...

[Robz888]

You know, I don't want to be too hard on Jimm here, because, this is a mistake that gets made. Stuff comes up ad we forget about deadline. there's a lot riding on it so it's terrible, but, well, we've all forgot orders before in one game or another.

The reason why I think it's a fair to be a little hard on him, or harder than if someone else had done this, is he kind of did this once before, in M-XIX. You gotta have better endgame control. These two-week final rounds only help scum, it appears.

[Robz888]

I will defend ash here. I don't think he played nearly as crazily as other people claim, and he made himself obviously town, which is a major benefit in the endgame! That Jim squandered unfortunately.

He lynched a PR with no chance to claim D1, he staunchly opposed a "broken" pro-town plan, he got into a huge town-v-town fight with the only remaining PR later, and he certainly didn't make himself obvious (in my opinion), and as far as I can tell, in the opinion of most (in-thread and in the spectator thread). Which is why I'm curious for ash's take.

The town v. town fight wasn't like his fault. TA accused him, wrongly.

[Voltgloss]

raerae won the game at m/237 in the mafia QT.  She just didn't know it at the time.

[Voltaire]

The town v. town fight wasn't like his fault. TA accused him, wrongly.

That's not how I took it at all. TA accused him because ash was playing scummy as heck, and ash didn't react well.

[Twistedarcher]

I will defend ash here. I don't think he played nearly as crazily as other people claim, and he made himself obviously town, which is a major benefit in the endgame! That Jim squandered unfortunately.

He lynched a PR with no chance to claim D1, he staunchly opposed a "broken" pro-town plan, he got into a huge town-v-town fight with the only remaining PR later, and he certainly didn't make himself obvious (in my opinion), and as far as I can tell, in the opinion of most (in-thread and in the spectator thread). Which is why I'm curious for ash's take.

The town v. town fight wasn't like his fault. TA accused him, wrongly.

Ash and I were both really stubborn and really wrong. Sorry, ash.

[Voltgloss]

m/169 in the mafia thread:  the real reason yuma won't allow Happily Ever After. 

[yuma]

m/169 in the mafia thread:  the real reason yuma won't allow Happily Ever After. 

Yes, that goes for everyone and every game. If a game ever goes to HEA I just won't include it in my stats... too much work.

[nkirbit]

well, we won I guess...

Hooray!

What was your other reason for wanting the 3-man lylo?

[liopoil]

really, I don't think HEA should ever happen. mods should just always do the modkill thing, or just not let them no lynch/no kill again.

[liopoil]

well, we won I guess...

Hooray!

What was your other reason for wanting the 3-man lylo?

At the time, I assumed we would kill Jimmmm and chairs, leaving mcmc-ash-raerae as the players at the end. I think either one of them would get lynched, as shown by ash saying mcmc was his top suspect in his reread during the night before he was NKed, and by mcmc deciding it was ashersky in the speccy QT. I think that lylo would be won easily. This one, not so much.

[liopoil]

does this game win the most no lynches award? I doubt there's ever been a game with 3 no lynches previously.