Yeah but how did that turn out? Oh wait shark_bait the cop got nightkilled, it's good you questioned it rather than just believing me.
He would have been nightkilled either way, you had already given the mafia all the info they needed when YOU TOLD GALZRIA HIS ROLE
Not my finest moment. But you'd have me tell everyone which is just beyond me. What happened to protecting power roles at all costs?
Ok to try and explain my stance I'll spell it out
Assume your town and not lying
1) Everyone including mafia can see your post.
2) Mafia know your not one of them and you already proved its not JUST a read.
3) So since mafia has full view of you're statement they will kill you, Mafia has incentive to kill people that are confirmed town and even more so on power roles.
4) So your statement has ALREADY caused you and O to die.
5) If your actually going to die you should give the information you have to the town so that if you do die town can believe you and have that information.
In this particular case your information clears TWO people so the mafia can only kill one of you and therefore your information is helpful to the town for at least a day.
Now this is how my stance has ALWAYS been on softish claims, for reference see BMMM1 where I was in fact town I always call out soft claims I do not support them one bit. UNLESS they're subtle but provable later like Axxle's Miller claim which someone stupidly asked him about (don't recall who right now).
Or eHal's jailkeeper claim in M3 these are claims I can get behind, they are provable but not so blatant that the scum faction will notice it for sure. Yours is one the scum team will pick up on for sure if you are indeed not scum. Maybe I'm wrong about it but I have a high suspicion that the softclaiming nature we have gotten into on f.DS is terrible.