I take back what I said about strongly considering the possibility Dsell is lying. I'll consider it still, but I sort of totally forgot that we could have a Mafia Roleblocker. Anyway, let's look at the possible scenarios for how Axxle lived:
A) Dsell is lying, and he did not shoot Axxle.
B) Dsell shot Axxle, but Dsell was roleblocked.
C) Dsell shot Axxle, but Axxle was protected by the doctor.
D) Dsell shot Axxle, but Axxle is one-shot immune.
I believe these are the only possible scenarios. Let's examine each of them.
C) This is the one that can be ruled out, I think. Everyone was comfortable with the Axxle shot, even Axxle (!). So if the town has a doctor, I don't know why he would cause such confusion. If he really didn't want Axxle to die, he would have objected to the plan. I also just don't think we have a doctor, at this point.
So I'm ruling out C. As for the rest.
A) If Dsell is lying, and did not shoot Axxle, I can think of only one reason: they are both mafia. Right? Why would Dsell put his reputation on the line if it wasn't worth saving Axxle to him? If Dsell is the SK, he would still want to kill Axxle, I think.
D) If D is true, it can only be true because Axxle is the SK. In this scenario, Dsell could be town or mafia.
B) Here's the most interesting one: the roleblocking one. So, I had totally forgotten about the Mafia Thief, the Roleblocker. Here is the description from the intro thread.
You are Mafia, a Mafia Thief {Roleblocker}. Your partner(s) are [Player Name(s)].
During the night phase you may talk with your partners here [QuickTopic link].
Each night phase, one of you or your partners may perform the factional kill.
Each night phase, you individually may perform a roleblock on another player in the game. You cannot block and kill in the same night.
You win when the Mafia obtain a majority or nothing can prevent this from occurring.
Emphasis mine. Let's say Axxle is the Mafia Thief. He knows he needs to protect himself, because he knows for sure Dsell will kill him. So he has to roleblock Dsell. This leaves him unable to perform the factional kill, because he can only do one or the other. This would explain why there was no mafia kill, and would mean that Axxle is the only remaining mafia.
So what about the SK kill? I would guess that we have a town roleblocker as well, and the town roleblocker hit the SK. I guess it's possible the SK did no kill. I guess it's also possible we have 2 mafia and no SK, although that seems really unbalanced, with all these townie one-shot vigs and other roles.
Anyway, in all scenarios, I think Axxle is a scum, and should probably be our lynch. Thoughts?