OK, so here's where I'm at (sorry for the stream of consciousness):
A lot of little things are nagging at me. Some of them are just things that hit me wrong, which is a dangerous judgement to make without the benefit of tone. Other things are simple inconsistencies. Since this is my first game ever, I don't know if the little inconsistencies are mafia slips, or folks operating with the same sense of "freedom" that being Town gives me. In no particular order:
1) The parallel posts in 2823 and 2824 from the wundertwins seems forced/contrived, as if to further advance the twinclaim. Especially the mirror of "nope this is stupid" with "this is silly".
2) Dsell preferring to shoot Frisk over Axxle2. I have more inconsistencies noted for Frisk than Axxle2, but my feeling is that Axxle has posted very little (I'm not necessarily referring to postcount), so for me that equates to lurking, which feels scummy. If Dsell is mafia, then he'd obviously want us to shoot Town (before dying tomorrow for being a liar), hoping that the results of the night are 3 more non-mafia dead. But if he's town, I think I agree with his preference of Frisk over Axxle2 to die.
3) Frisk, in 1796, asserted that he wanted to hammer Jo "on principal" [sic], but he was not willing to hammer by Iphone. (It seemed weird to sacrifice principle over the type of voting machinery, but whatever). Yet in 2814, Frisk expresses willingness to unvote by phone. Interestingly, the original inaction helped Jo. The action of unvoting (if taken) would help Jo. And the tagline in 2814 ("someone cop claims i guess?") just feels like coaching (or concealed rolefishing) to me.
4) Pops being so inscrutable/unhelpful feels non-town to me in general. It mimics O, but that is guilt by association.And you all have made it clear that that's just Pops being Pops. Folks thought my early posting was unhelpful too.
5) Pops very early (and adamant) defense of me (371) was strange. Our later tete a tete about the issue didn't leave me feeling any better. If he's town, he's not done a good job of answering questions from someone he's convinced is town. If he's mafia, he's done a good job of helping me ascribe that unwillingness to help to something akin to benign neglect of a lesser/newer player, rather than evidence of mafia play. Which worries me.
6) Robz has started worrying me a little. He changes his mind a lot, after making good cases against people, and now seems to want to move pretty quickly through all the design, build, and sell stages of this current deal. Maybe that just means Axxle has written something that stuck with me (2803). Though maybe Axxle was just parroting Jo in 2802.
There are other examples, but I'm really tired of going over the thread for documentation purposes. I don't know that I will pass on the deal of lynch Jo, shoot Axxle just because I might slightly favor the second part being shoot Frisk rather than Axxle, but I need to think a bit more, because this feels like voting for two people with one vote.