I really, really can't buy jo being mafia. His similarity to O's playstyle - I can't buy they'd both play like that. But I can sort of buy jo as an SK. Currently I think Robz the more likely SK. So I don't want to lynch jo. I do think he's town.
You could sell me on CF/Axxle. If you want to try and sell me on this plan, tell me what jo's flip tells us? Because his erratic play has made suspecting him completely defensible, so I don't think there's anyone who would look more or less scummy based on jo's flip.
I want to know why jo's death helps us if he flips town.
Actually, I think I figure that out myself. Forgive me if this is a little rough.
So if we kill jo and he comes up town, and DSell's kill on Axxle goes through, we're left with
DSell - we'll know one way or another, see below
Robz - probably the SK if jo isn't
CF - scum suspect #1
me - I know I'm town
pops - next most likely scum by POE?
Tables - basically confirmed town
SFS - basically confirmed town
Minus whoever the two scumteams kill (if DSell is telling the truth) or whoevever the other scumteam kills (If DSell is scum), unless Axxle or J is the serial killer. So we'll have 5 - 7 people left, and worse case scenario 3 scum. Either way, we'll know one way or the other if DSell is scum. If he is, we lynch him, and we might still have 2 scum to deal with, but we'll have a lot of information to find them. But they'll kill someone the night we lynch Dsell. So then we'll have 3 to 4 people left and up to 2 scum. If those two are on the same team, we lose. But I think our chances of not hitting the other scum during that time seem pretty low to me. Chances are even if we double mislynch we can still pull a win.
I have a scum read on Axxle, and I accept that jo might be SK, but I can't say I'm one hundred percent comfortable with this plan. At least I can say if jo flips town, Robz is most likely SK. That's not nothing.
The more I think about it, the more I can get behind this.
I'm in. Sorry for the wall-o-text.