since we know Vigs were not responsible for those kills
This is not a fact. Grujah could have killed insomniac / theorel - and either collided with a mafia kill / sk kill OR there could have been random protection.
But Grujah only had one-shot. So then the SK collided was was blocked on whatever day Grujah did the kill, and not on the other day? Yeah, that's possible.
@RobZ
What % chance do you believe DSell is telling the truth?
If he is town, what is the value of his un-used kill vs. the uncertainty that having him alive causes - as I don't believe we can clear him short of an investigative roleclaim.
Asking myself these questions - I am starting to view lynching DSell as the "safe" play - and then look at everyone's interactions with DSell and his reads in that context on Day 4. If DSell is SK, we're down to 1 night kill. Even if he isn't, the worst that we're down to is 3 town - 2 mafia - 1 serial killer after the night.
The fact that DSell doesn't want to announce his kill target makes me slightly suspicious - but I can see both arguments.
Frisk, I can't put a % chance on it. I'm probably 55-45 in favor of him being a liar. I really don't know, though. At this point I think any combination is possible. There's just nothing to rule out, anymore. We could have Tables the Sk and Jo and Pops mafia. We could have Dsell and Axxle mafia and Frisk the SK. We could have Jo the SK and Axxle and Frisk the mafia.
I think it's going to be easier to pick up the pieces tomorrow when, like, a quarter of us are dead.
A good reason to keep Dsell alive anyway is that it puts the mafia and SK in an awkward position regarding him. SK doesn't know whether he's mafia or town, mafia doesn't know whether he's SK or town. There's a chance he doesn't use his shot, in which case they would regret not killing him up, but neither the mafia nor SK want to overlap a kill with each other. So do they go for him? If he dies, or there are three deaths, we learn the truth about him. Do they not kill him, or anyone, in order to make him look suspicious? But if he's neither, and both groups do that, we could actually have a night of no deaths! Which is good.
So I think keeping Dsell alive might be worth the nighttime consternation it causes our enemies, regardless of what role it is. It might result in us getting lucky.