I'm looking at the names on the lists so far, and it's interesting. Ideally I'd like DSell and Frisk's opinions, but I'll continue as is for now.
I'll also point out I've simplified the lists slightly, to a binary system (high/low). If you dislike how I simplified what you said, point it out and I'll see how if affects things. I'm also not going to bother formatting this because, lazy, but you should get the gist of it (first name is the user, remaining names are the people they wanted to vote, in the order they gave).
Galz Pops Joth Axxle Grujah Glooble DSell
Dsell
Robz Galz O Joth Grujah
Frisk
O Pops Joth Glooble Grujah
Glooble O Grujah Pops Galz Axxle
Pops Galz O Grujah Axxle2
Tables O Joth Pops Grujah
Grujah Axxle O Glooble Joth
Joth Axxle Grujah Pops Galz O
SFS Joth Grujah
Axxle Galz O Grujah Joth Glooble Pops
Firstly everyone that's submitted a list except Grujah is happy with him being lynched. This makes me more confident he's town, as either the mafia have decided they're happy to bus him, or the mafia know he's somewhat scummy and can easily make him look suspicious. ... Did I mention the dream I had a few days/week ago? This is remarkably like that scenario. Of the two options, the second seems far more likely - there's no especially good case against Grujah except, he's been lurking.
The next two highest are Joth and O. Joth isn't a candidate of Pops (who gave a good reason for not wanting to lynch Joth (today) and Glooble (who is of course the twinclaim). O isn't a candidate of Galz or SFS, neither of whom have given good reasons for not putting him on (hardly surprising, as he hasn't been the focus of discussion for good chunks of two days...). This makes me somewhat uncomfortable - Galz isn't one of my scumreads and neither is SFS, so by my own logic this would likely make the mafia be trying to egg an O lynch on.
Next are Galz and Pops - notably who both put each other first on their lists (I don't know whether their lists were fully ordered though). I think I said this before of them, but I feel like they're two town members getting at each other's throats with the mafia pushing them. But... only Glooble, Axxle and Joth listed both as suspects (and Axxle has Galz top, Pops bottom). So if the mafia are pushing for suspicion onto both of them, they're being very careful, or otherwise are some of the three listed people. I'd actually be willing to cede one is likely mafia (and I personally think Pops as mentioned), but unlikely both.
Axxle is also there on 5, interestingly with the two most frequently elected candidates putting him top, and lower elected candidates putting him bottom.
I think I'm going to try and re-analyse this tomorrow afternoon, although that really doesn't give us much time. But for now (at risk of being accused of casting the first stone) I think O is probably the best candidate. He's not unanimously chosen and is the highest chosen excluding those, and of those electing him, he's the first or second pick 6 times out of 7.