Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[O]

Probably O.  "I have to wagon at one point" was soooo not his attitude day 1. 

But then I got flackx1000 for "not being willing to join on either of the major wagons", and nobody was willing to join my popswagon.

I really don't think me or Galz is scum.

And what happens when we lynch me or Galz and either of us flips town?

[O]

inb4omgfreudianslipomgscum. I KNOW I'm not scum, I highly suspect Galz is town. Kthx.

[Galzria]

Probably O.  "I have to wagon at one point" was soooo not his attitude day 1. 

But then I got flackx1000 for "not being willing to join on either of the major wagons", and nobody was willing to join my popswagon.

I really don't think me or Galz is scum.

And what happens when we lynch me or Galz and either of us flips town?

I joined your Pops wagon D1...

I should've stayed on it instead of going with Axxle. We would be down 1 scum in this town.

[popsofctown]

Probably O.  "I have to wagon at one point" was soooo not his attitude day 1. 

But then I got flackx1000 for "not being willing to join on either of the major wagons", and nobody was willing to join my popswagon.

I really don't think me or Galz is scum.

And what happens when we lynch me or Galz and either of us flips town?

I joined your Pops wagon D1...

I should've stayed on it instead of going with Axxle. We would be down 1 scum in this town.

You, after my flip.

[Galzria]

Probably O.  "I have to wagon at one point" was soooo not his attitude day 1. 

But then I got flackx1000 for "not being willing to join on either of the major wagons", and nobody was willing to join my popswagon.

I really don't think me or Galz is scum.

And what happens when we lynch me or Galz and either of us flips town?

I joined your Pops wagon D1...

I should've stayed on it instead of going with Axxle. We would be down 1 scum in this town.

You, after my flip.

Wow, that's the best defense I've ever seen! Pops is TOTALLY pro.

[popsofctown]

cool your jets before i start to blush

[Galzria]

Vote: Popsoftown

[jotheonah]

Well two days before deadline is definitely the best time to be starting a bunch of new wagons. I'm so glad superrobz cut in when he did. We were getting dangerously close to actually accomplishing something.

[Captain_Frisk]

Well two days before deadline is definitely the best time to be starting a bunch of new wagons. I'm so glad superrobz cut in when he did. We were getting dangerously close to actually accomplishing something.

Do you really think that Grujah is mafia? 

[jotheonah]

There's two possible mafia subsets in my mind. One of them (the lurker mafia theory) almost certainly includes Grujah.

So yes, I believe he could be mafia.

[popsofctown]

Ok.  This is going to be some refereeing, but it's necessary:

It is bad to nolynch in mafia.  I probably won't be able to convince Robz of this, but it's mathematically superior to lynch at random rather than not lynch at all, and it logically follows from the game's premises that lynching is superior to nolynching unless and absurdly larger amount of information is going to arrive on future days, and that doesn't happen in well designed mafia games.  It does happen in Dethy, but I'm going to assume this is a game with less than eleventeen investigative roles.

Everyone needs to make a list of people that they are willing to lynch today.  Technically, that list should include everyone but Tables, but for most people there's several players that are such undesirable lynches to you that you would use the risk of no-lynch to your advantage to get a lynch you prefer (google "the ultimatum game" and figure out the relevance, perhaps).  That's dangerous territory.
If we have a last day deadline scramble, instead of risking no-lynch we can just synthesize the lists and find a consensus lynch.

I would lynch Galzria, O, Grujah, and Axxle2 if I had to in a Darkest hour

[popsofctown]

JOTH IS ROCKIN THA PRISMZ

[jotheonah]

Ok, I looked that one up on MafiaScum and couldn't find it. Prisms?

[O]

I don't know how you all manage to get these sets of scumtells. The only linkages I have are Robz-Grujah and the extremely unlikely Table-SFS, and those are pairs, not trios. 

[popsofctown]

it's part of my iso this game, it's not really a thing.

[O]

Willing to lynch (in order of preference): Popsofctown, Jotheonah, Glooble, Grujah, Robz
Strong-unwilling: Tables, SFS, DSell (due to V/LA)
Still-pretty-damn-unwilling: Captain Frisk, Axxle, Galzria

[jotheonah]

I used "subsets" specifically. I don't have groups. I have some different possible scenarios and they each include a spattering of possible candidates. I guess the short answer to Frisk's question was "Yes." I wouldn't vote for someone I knew to be town, with one exception.

Lynches I'm OK with today: Axxle, Grujah, pops, (Galz, O)
I'm tempted to include myself on that list, but I'll limit it to folks who might actually be scum.

Parentheses for would rather not but could do in a pinch.

[Glooble]

following the same format:

O, Grujah, pops (Galz, Axxle2)

[Axxle]

Galz, O, Grujah, (Joth, Glooble, pops)

[Galzria]

I don't know how you all manage to get these sets of scumtells. The only linkages I have are Robz-Grujah and the extremely unlikely Table-SFS, and those are pairs, not trios.

 

it's part of my iso this game, it's not really a thing.

 

pairings without flips are dumb.

[jotheonah]

I don't know how you all manage to get these sets of scumtells. The only linkages I have are Robz-Grujah and the extremely unlikely Table-SFS, and those are pairs, not trios.

 

it's part of my iso this game, it's not really a thing.

 

pairings without flips are dumb.

I think "part of my iso" was in response to my question about prisms, not to O's question about pairings, which was directed at me.

QUOTE BUTTON IS OUR FRIEND.

[Captain_Frisk]

Before we start providing ranked lists, can we agree on the methodology of choosing our group lynch target?

Otherwise, I'm sure most of our lists will include some subset of Jonah, galz, pops, glooble, and we will be right back here, and I'm not going to agree to vote on a "consensus" lynch if there isn't a predefined way to select the target.

[Galzria]

Anyway, to keep with format since I actually think Pops makes a valid point about not No-Lynching. In order from highest to lowest desire to lynch:

Glad to see gone: Pops, Jotheonah, Axxle
Willing to lynch: Grujah, Glooble, Dsell
Would rather not: Robz, C.F., O
Won't lynch: Tables, SFS, Myself

[Galzria]

I don't know how you all manage to get these sets of scumtells. The only linkages I have are Robz-Grujah and the extremely unlikely Table-SFS, and those are pairs, not trios.

 

it's part of my iso this game, it's not really a thing.

 

pairings without flips are dumb.

I think "part of my iso" was in response to my question about prisms, not to O's question about pairings, which was directed at me.

QUOTE BUTTON IS OUR FRIEND.

Don't buy it. If you want I will produce the countless posts Pops has made where he claims that if he doesn't quote, his response was to the preceding post.

[O]

Ugggghhhhhhhhh

Will be REAL (as in, no internet access) V/LA very very soon for about ~48 hours. I want a lynch, so I'm going to park myself on the most likely consensus vote that I would still like to see a lynch of.

VOTE:Popsofctown unless anyone has any better ideas.

BTW Pops totally stole my meta from... every forum Mafia game. I've always said random lynch>nolynch, and you narbs never believed me.