All right... that's alot of crazy $stuff for a Friday night.
RobZ's analysis of similarity between Grujah and Axxle1 band wagons is spot on - in that it is damn near the same wagon that mislynched on day 1.
Options are:
1. We're all town and were terrible at this game day 1.
2. There is mafia on this wagon and we're about to mislynch
3. There is mafia on this wagon bussing Grujah - and hoping we'll back out because the wagon looks too similar.
I had no idea when I started this wagon that it would end up looking the same - hence the unvote. I've now gone back and read every post since my vote (#1966) twice. Now I would consider my argument on lynching to be medium quality
at best. The gist of it is: he lurks, and all things being equal, he is a better mislynch than others. This is a far weaker argument than everything against J, and Galz's argument against Pops.
Here are the things that stood out:
#1967 - Glooble gets on the bandwagon super early - sheeping my "read" This is Glooble playing exactly the same way that has gotten him called scum in the past.
#1972,#1973,#1974 - BAM BAM BAM
Pops, Jonah, O all jump on the wagon within 7(!!!!) minutes. Pops uses my argument. J uses no argument as usual. O provides no information - as per the O playbook.
#1977 - Galz points out that this is freaking crazy. This post is the definition of hedging / fence sitting, which I don't have as much issue with as others (hell, my unvote is also hedging). J points out as much in #1978 - hedging while placing the blame for this hedge on G. O sheeps this hedge in #1979. Pops sheeps the hedge in #1981.
We all feel terrible for this mislynch about to happen Since we have so many people sitting on the fence - it can't be a scumtell.
#1980 - Galz joins the wagon - ostensibly for pressure purposes.
#1982/3 - RobZ shows up with 2 stone tablets and commands us to stop. I especially enjoyed this:
I'd bet 3 or 4 of you are getting seriously outplayed by the 2 or 3 of you who are mafia.
Since I am not mafia, and I started the wagon, I'm wondering how I've been outplayed - but I can totally see his perspective.
#1985 - Glooble backs off
#1987 - RobZ points out that this bandwagon does not have a good track record.
O and RobZ have a little fight about how many mafia is on the wagon. For the record - the starting point of my analysis was "at least 1 mafia on the Axxle1 wagon"
#1997 - Axxle2 - Real life drinking excuse for not voting. Same scummy contentless post count inflating crap that got Axxle1 lynched (falsely - for those who might not remember what happened 40 pages ago)
#1999 - Jonah re-pushed the wagon with a SK theory.
I'm standing by this lynch and waiting for the flip.
#2000 (WOOHOOOOOOO) - RobZ calls for an analysis of how scummy Galz, Frisk, Jonah, and Glooble are.
#2002 - Jonah points a semi FOS @ Robz.
#2003 - 90 seconds later: hedge on RobZ -> semi FOS @ CF.
#2005 - O starts up some distraction with a crazytrain vote on me.
#2007 - RobZ hints that he's ok with no-lynch
#2010 - Jonah FoS @ O.
#2013 - Galz (probably overly strongly) points out that RobZ has semi 8 / 12 people. He overexaggerates a few points in my mind (RobZ, Axxle2) - and a slight exxagerations on others (DSell, Pops)
#2014 - Jonah wants to kill kill kill. Doesn't realize that he's already been put on the group W bench.
#2020 - RobZ calls Galz out on #2013.
However:
Dsell - No opinion one way or the other. But when I have 5 or so strong suspects, yes, he's safely acquitted.
There are 12 of us alive. RobZ in this post points out that he has townreads on 7 of them. Presumably he has a town read on himself (#8). That leaves 4 people. Who are these 5 strong suspects?
#2024 - O rejoins wagon.
- dick slamming contest between O / Robz ...
#2033 - Galz calls out RobZ on #2020
#2053 - Jonah FoS's O and Galz.
#2054 - Jonah reminds us that he was suspicious of RobZ.
#2066 - Grujah wakes up to find himself with a noose around his neck standing under a treebranch.
#2069 - Jonah wants to kill kill kill - dissects Grujah's not me post. Jonah should know as well as anyone that it doesn't matter what you say when you're about to be lynched, it will be flipped right back in your face.
#2072 - SFS declines to join the wagon. With SFS and tables not on the wagon - if you believe they are both town, the odds of a mafia lynch are very low.
Vote: Jotheonah - he keeps pushing for the kill - while throwing the FOS at everyone in the universe.
I don't like RobZ after this exchange either, but the only meaningful thing that Jonah did was tear apart Grujah's defense post. Since I am inclined to think that lynching mafia is unlikely without the assistance of Tables / SFS, I read this as trying to incite town into a mislynch (which was oh - so - close) while simultaneously muddying the waters all over the place with fingers of suspicion.