Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[WestCoastDidds]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

[WestCoastDidds]

Unvote

Just backing off the L-1 for a beat or two

[A Drowned Kernel]

For the record, I feel like tying people up to jailkeep them is a bit of a stretch.  What if he's a scum roleblocker and made up the doc part?

Weird, I presumed one of skip/mail had the rope-becomes-JK part.

Mail-mi's obv!town btw. Hammer withdrawn

How so?

[Galzria]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

[WestCoastDidds]

There are a handful of us here....lynch MM, lynch skip, or no lynch are the most plausible options.

The stuff component make a lynch more consequential than usual (and interesting! Thanks Glooble!) so not lynching is perhaps advantageous.

Unless a ball cap is not at all valuable....

[WestCoastDidds]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

Come on, Galzy. Drop some knowledge on me.

[mail-mi]

Point of note: Skip is the first to claim an item, in post #100. So before even ADK's plan, Skip is out there claiming stuff. Sounds like a way to goad out other claims, which is scummy.

He also continually clarifies himself about his "I have an item to give to someone plan." I find myself correcting my plans and finetuning them unnecessarily more as scum so I don't get caught with a bad, scummy plan.

Before skip goes for me, he's not pushing a 1v1. He's keeping his options open, asking others about what he should do, etc. Not until after I post does he vote for me, and he does say he's going to leave it there for the rest of the day. So he pushes the 1v1 more than I thought he did, but what else does he do at that point?

He also allows me to claim the item first, leaving all his options open again.

Also, his defense at post 316 is perfect for tomorrow when I flip town. "Come on, you think I'd do this as scum? I'm not that dumb." It's a bunch of WIFOM that doesn't turn out to be a good defense.

Also there's his unreasonable expectation of me, which Galz pointed out, that no other person who posted a list said "Whoa this is a potential 1v1, we should look into this." Not necessarily alignment indicative, but it's still there.

[mail-mi]

There are a handful of us here....lynch MM, lynch skip, or no lynch are the most plausible options.

The stuff component make a lynch more consequential than usual (and interesting! Thanks Glooble!) so not lynching is perhaps advantageous.

Unless a ball cap is not at all valuable....

For the record, the description of the baseball cap doesn't give me any hints as to what it could be used for or who needs it.

[Galzria]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

Come on, Galzy. Drop some knowledge on me.

I'm waitin' on you! No?

[jotheonah]

I for one am unimpressed with the claim. A scum jailkeeper is a little weird, but not impossible, especially if this is multiball. And he could absolutely just be a roleblocker. Or it could all be a lie.

I'm a little skeptical that scum would be weak enough that they have to work for their PR(s) but of course we don't have nearly enough info to make that judgement.

That said, if we don't have the votes to lynch mail-mi and we have an hour left... skip? ADK (I liked Galz's case)?

I really doubt we can get a non-skip non-mail-mi lynch through. So if we don't have the votes for mail-mi, I guess I can switch to skip to get a lynch. Maybe skip should claim too at this point?

ppe: a bunch

[sudgy]

Note that from my reads post I townread skip now, so I don't want to lynch him.

[jotheonah]

I guess if someone needs the ball cap, and thinks it very valuable, now would be the time to claim that.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I guess I can switch to skip to get a lynch.

Convenient

[sudgy]

Point of note: Skip is the first to claim an item, in post #100. So before even ADK's plan, Skip is out there claiming stuff. Sounds like a way to goad out other claims, which is scummy.

He also continually clarifies himself about his "I have an item to give to someone plan." I find myself correcting my plans and finetuning them unnecessarily more as scum so I don't get caught with a bad, scummy plan.

Before skip goes for me, he's not pushing a 1v1. He's keeping his options open, asking others about what he should do, etc. Not until after I post does he vote for me, and he does say he's going to leave it there for the rest of the day. So he pushes the 1v1 more than I thought he did, but what else does he do at that point?

He also allows me to claim the item first, leaving all his options open again.

Also, his defense at post 316 is perfect for tomorrow when I flip town. "Come on, you think I'd do this as scum? I'm not that dumb." It's a bunch of WIFOM that doesn't turn out to be a good defense.

Also there's his unreasonable expectation of me, which Galz pointed out, that no other person who posted a list said "Whoa this is a potential 1v1, we should look into this." Not necessarily alignment indicative, but it's still there.

I find all of this to be a bit silly, because I feel like all of the stuff skip has done makes sense as town.

[WestCoastDidds]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

Come on, Galzy. Drop some knowledge on me.

I'm waitin' on you! No?

Not me. I don’t need the baseball cap, and I don’t have any guesses

[WestCoastDidds]

I find all of this to be a bit silly, because I feel like all of the stuff skip has done makes sense as town.

Like if it was town v town

[jotheonah]

Unofficial Vote Count

skip wooznum (6): Awaclus, mail-mi, scolapasta, MiX, Joseph2303, Galzria
mail-mi (6): skip wooznum, LaLight, faust, A Drowned Kernel, sudgy, jotheonah
Awaclus (1): Eevee
Not voting (1): DatSwan

[MiX]

I don't have a big enough scumread on anyone else.

I blame short day.

[jotheonah]

I guess I can switch to skip to get a lynch.

Convenient

 

A lynch I'm less sure about is better than no lynch! What a striking, bold, original thought never before articulated in a game of mafia. Come off it.

[mail-mi]

Point of note: Skip is the first to claim an item, in post #100. So before even ADK's plan, Skip is out there claiming stuff. Sounds like a way to goad out other claims, which is scummy.

He also continually clarifies himself about his "I have an item to give to someone plan." I find myself correcting my plans and finetuning them unnecessarily more as scum so I don't get caught with a bad, scummy plan.

Before skip goes for me, he's not pushing a 1v1. He's keeping his options open, asking others about what he should do, etc. Not until after I post does he vote for me, and he does say he's going to leave it there for the rest of the day. So he pushes the 1v1 more than I thought he did, but what else does he do at that point?

He also allows me to claim the item first, leaving all his options open again.

Also, his defense at post 316 is perfect for tomorrow when I flip town. "Come on, you think I'd do this as scum? I'm not that dumb." It's a bunch of WIFOM that doesn't turn out to be a good defense.

Also there's his unreasonable expectation of me, which Galz pointed out, that no other person who posted a list said "Whoa this is a potential 1v1, we should look into this." Not necessarily alignment indicative, but it's still there.

I find all of this to be a bit silly, because I feel like all of the stuff skip has done makes sense as town.

It also makes sense as scum. Scum want to make sense as well, you see.

[Galzria]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

Come on, Galzy. Drop some knowledge on me.

I'm waitin' on you! No?

Not me. I don’t need the baseball cap, and I don’t have any guesses

Ah, well, nevermind then. I'll say that if I *had* the baseball cap to give, you would've been the person I sent it to. But I don't know any more about it than you do it seems.

[sudgy]

Point of note: Skip is the first to claim an item, in post #100. So before even ADK's plan, Skip is out there claiming stuff. Sounds like a way to goad out other claims, which is scummy.

He also continually clarifies himself about his "I have an item to give to someone plan." I find myself correcting my plans and finetuning them unnecessarily more as scum so I don't get caught with a bad, scummy plan.

Before skip goes for me, he's not pushing a 1v1. He's keeping his options open, asking others about what he should do, etc. Not until after I post does he vote for me, and he does say he's going to leave it there for the rest of the day. So he pushes the 1v1 more than I thought he did, but what else does he do at that point?

He also allows me to claim the item first, leaving all his options open again.

Also, his defense at post 316 is perfect for tomorrow when I flip town. "Come on, you think I'd do this as scum? I'm not that dumb." It's a bunch of WIFOM that doesn't turn out to be a good defense.

Also there's his unreasonable expectation of me, which Galz pointed out, that no other person who posted a list said "Whoa this is a potential 1v1, we should look into this." Not necessarily alignment indicative, but it's still there.

I find all of this to be a bit silly, because I feel like all of the stuff skip has done makes sense as town.

It also makes sense as scum. Scum want to make sense as well, you see.

Yeah, but scum is statistically less likely than town.  You want to find stuff that makes sense as scum but not as town.

[Galzria]

Point of note: Skip is the first to claim an item, in post #100. So before even ADK's plan, Skip is out there claiming stuff. Sounds like a way to goad out other claims, which is scummy.

He also continually clarifies himself about his "I have an item to give to someone plan." I find myself correcting my plans and finetuning them unnecessarily more as scum so I don't get caught with a bad, scummy plan.

Before skip goes for me, he's not pushing a 1v1. He's keeping his options open, asking others about what he should do, etc. Not until after I post does he vote for me, and he does say he's going to leave it there for the rest of the day. So he pushes the 1v1 more than I thought he did, but what else does he do at that point?

He also allows me to claim the item first, leaving all his options open again.

Also, his defense at post 316 is perfect for tomorrow when I flip town. "Come on, you think I'd do this as scum? I'm not that dumb." It's a bunch of WIFOM that doesn't turn out to be a good defense.

Also there's his unreasonable expectation of me, which Galz pointed out, that no other person who posted a list said "Whoa this is a potential 1v1, we should look into this." Not necessarily alignment indicative, but it's still there.

I find all of this to be a bit silly, because I feel like all of the stuff skip has done makes sense as town.

It also makes sense as scum. Scum want to make sense as well, you see.

Yeah, but scum is statistically less likely than town.  You want to find stuff that makes sense as scum but not as town.

And scum tries to do things that make sense as town, not as scum. C'mon. This circle can play 'round all day.

[WestCoastDidds]

What could a baseball cap do? If MM gets lynched, whomever needs the cap can’t get it.

What indeed.

Come on, Galzy. Drop some knowledge on me.

I'm waitin' on you! No?

Not me. I don’t need the baseball cap, and I don’t have any guesses

Ah, well, nevermind then. I'll say that if I *had* the baseball cap to give, you would've been the person I sent it to. But I don't know any more about it than you do it seems.

I definitely need something but that’s not it!

[sudgy]

Unofficial Vote Count

skip wooznum (6): Awaclus, mail-mi, scolapasta, MiX, Joseph2303, Galzria
mail-mi (6): skip wooznum, LaLight, faust, A Drowned Kernel, sudgy, jotheonah
Awaclus (1): Eevee
Not voting (1): DatSwan

Something's not right here, you have 14 people listed here when 15 are playing.