Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[cayvie]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

[Greathallscout]

@mix okay so maybe broken was too strong-but i think my point is valid that we can come up with a really towny plan.

[Uncleeurope]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

”‘Kill him!’ is thy cry? Is this what thy plea?
To have me die in front of all of thee?
I bid’st that thou wait, ’til the next Highstorm
Where more will be known, while bunk’d in thy dorm.”

[MiX]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

My guess is that he cannot do it, or simply that he doesn't want to do it. Why would you NK him when you can just cooperate with him as scum?

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

”‘Kill him!’ is thy cry? Is this what thy plea?
To have me die in front of all of thee?
I bid’st that thou wait, ’til the next Highstorm
Where more will be known, while bunk’d in thy dorm.”

...tsk! I have no doubt you're not scum. Why would we wait?

[WestCoastDidds]

I wish to play to win, and you clearly are not playing to win nor for me to win. So, why keep you around?

It's sooooo anti-town. I am feeling the same frustration I have with you when you say "everyone would do it this way"...Eddie decides what he thinks is fun and applies to everyone despite the fact that we helped him get what he needed.

I don't understand why Glooble is just like "eh, cool". He burned his IC status today to help Eddie and Eddie is now opting out of helping town.

[MiX]

I wish to play to win, and you clearly are not playing to win nor for me to win. So, why keep you around?

It's sooooo anti-town. I am feeling the same frustration I have with you when you say "everyone would do it this way"...Eddie decides what he thinks is fun and applies to everyone despite the fact that we helped him get what he needed.

I don't understand why Glooble is just like "eh, cool". He burned his IC status today to help Eddie and Eddie is now opting out of helping town.

I presume they talked it out, and this was the compromise. I kinda wanna hear what Glooble's saying about this.

[Greathallscout]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

Can't he only agree to a plan where he is doctored or something? his plan seems more dangerous

ppe  @mix then scum loses the strength to their abilities? Isnt that the point of this whole glooble-eddie plan?

[Rhand]

I proposed a plan to Eddie.

“I have refused his plan. I have never liked “tell the IC everything” games, so I will not be taking part in delivering anyone’s role info to Glooble. I do this in order to keep the game engaging and fun for all parties.”

So you have actively been trying to get (at least) 3 people to claim to you in private, but a plan with helping an IC organise the Night is too much?
If it’s about the fun of the mafia team, we can only do this until our first storm Night because that Night mafia can kill anyone without interference.

[MiX]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

Can't he only agree to a plan where he is doctored or something? his plan seems more dangerous

ppe  @mix then scum loses the strength to their abilities? Isnt that the point of this whole glooble-eddie plan?

No, because Eddie can lie to Glooble as scum wants him to, or something. He could also tell scum everyone's roles and stuff.

[Glooble]

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

[scolapasta]

Yeah, Eddie, I don't get the not going with the plan because it would make the game less fun. I mean if that's true, we just finish this game and move on to Memento (or whatever's next).

I mean, you've got to play to win. So there's clearly something else you're not telling us, some other reason you don't want to help town.

[MiX]

Vote: hypercube

I'm gonna assume there was a plan between him and Glooble, and he can't risk going with his plan before a Highstorm. I trust Glooble in this as he's the one that knows the most about Uncle.

[Uncleeurope]

”I am playing to win.”

[WestCoastDidds]

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

Can you say more Glooble (its okay if you can't). It just seems like we are (collectively) getting played.

[WestCoastDidds]

I trust Glooble, but I am not sure that Eddie is playing to win is the same as town't playing to win.

vote: chairs who hasn't done anything remotely helpful to town.

[cayvie]

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

we also need you to live that long too, correct?

[Glooble]

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

Can you say more Glooble (its okay if you can't). It just seems like we are (collectively) getting played.

Saying more would give scum too much.

[MiX]

”I am playing to win.”

I stepped out of line when I said you weren't. I'm sorry.

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

Can you say more Glooble (its okay if you can't). It just seems like we are (collectively) getting played.

I think we need to trust Glooble on this...a public consensus seems worse than him deciding by himself, and there's probably some hidden information that should remain hidden.

This better change after the highstorm.

PPE 2: Just get some other IC, hopefully that was an order power.

[cayvie]

If we lynch Eddie tonight then I burned my IC for nothing.

We need him to live through the first highstorm.

Also, this first sentence is what marks say when they're being scammed.

"If I back out of this sure plan to make $2000 now, I'll be down the $10 I've already invested!"

[Greathallscout]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

My guess is that he cannot do it, or simply that he doesn't want to do it. Why would you NK him when you can just cooperate with him as scum?

sorry im confused.

What did you mean by cooperate with him as scum? i thought you meant follow the glooble-eddie plan.

No, because Eddie can lie to Glooble as scum wants him to, or something. He could also tell scum everyone's roles and stuff.

why would scum trust glooble? I think I'm missing something.

[Uncleeurope]

”There is no guerentee that all Knights with the same order have the same extra power, yes?”

[Rhand]

I think Eddie should tell someone he trusts of his choosing the plan too. If the first Highstorm comes at Night, we lose Glooble and will never know what they agreed.

[Uncleeurope]

I think Eddie should tell someone he trusts of his choosing the plan too. If the first Highstorm comes at Night, we lose Glooble and will never know what they agreed.

“I was thinks it about this, too...”

[Greathallscout]

In addition, each Order has access to 1 role power that is unique to their Order. They can use this power each night if they have the Stormlight for it. (This means that a Knight Radiant can take up to 3 actions each night: 1 from each Surge and their Order-specific action).

sounds like each order has the same extra power

[MiX]

vote: Eddie

My guess: Eddie doesn't want this plan because it makes him a prime nightkill target. Understandable, if he does not win with the town. I am so fine with lynching a survivor-esque role.

My guess is that he cannot do it, or simply that he doesn't want to do it. Why would you NK him when you can just cooperate with him as scum?

sorry im confused.

What did you mean by cooperate with him as scum? i thought you meant follow the glooble-eddie plan.

No, because Eddie can lie to Glooble as scum wants him to, or something. He could also tell scum everyone's roles and stuff.

why would scum trust glooble? I think I'm missing something.

I mean that when Eddie's collecting claims from people, scum can just claim they're scum and cooperate with Eddie.

”There is no guerentee that all Knights with the same order have the same extra power, yes?”

Each order has a specific power, but given faust's claim, there can be Knights that have an unique power unrelated to their order.

I think Eddie should tell someone he trusts of his choosing the plan too. If the first Highstorm comes at Night, we lose Glooble and will never know what they agreed.

“I was thinks it about this, too...”

Would the second IC please stand up. I pick LL (and myself, wow).